My bread in my bread maker rises and then falls down just after cooking starts





.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty{ margin-bottom:0;
}







9















I really need some help!
Every time I try to bake some bread in my bread maker, the bread rises at first but just when cooking process starts and the device increases the heat, the dough fall down!
I tried several recipes with white bread, french bread, whole wheat bread with various amounts but always this happens.



My device is Even Baker XBM 1029S. There is not much info about this model but it seems to be a clone of "Cookworks Signature Breadmaker". The same menu, LCD, Buttons.



enter image description here










share|improve this question




















  • 8





    There's more than one type of dried yeast. There's active dry yeast and instant dry yeast, and there's a difference.

    – GdD
    May 14 at 14:54






  • 1





    @GdD : but would it have even risen with the wrong yeast? This is almost behaving more like a souffle ... so maybe insufficient gluten development? Or it's not actually heating correctly to cook the bread (but the picture looks to be a shell of crust and a fallen middle? Or is that the pan on the outside?)

    – Joe
    May 14 at 15:06






  • 4





    It can make a big difference. Active dry yeast is slower acting than instant yeast. If you use instant yeast or too much active yeast the dough rises too quickly and can collapse.

    – GdD
    May 14 at 15:09






  • 2





    I agree with @GdD, the dough has risen too fast. Make sure that you are using a bread machine recipe - not all bread recipes survive the transition to a bread machine, often machine breads need less yeast, and more gluten. Actually I am going to make this into a more comprehensive answer.

    – bob1
    May 14 at 15:31








  • 1





    Are you using all purpose flour, cake flour or bread flour? Specialized bread flours (aka strong flours) have a much higher gluten content and so are more resistant to collapsing.

    – Vality
    May 14 at 18:25


















9















I really need some help!
Every time I try to bake some bread in my bread maker, the bread rises at first but just when cooking process starts and the device increases the heat, the dough fall down!
I tried several recipes with white bread, french bread, whole wheat bread with various amounts but always this happens.



My device is Even Baker XBM 1029S. There is not much info about this model but it seems to be a clone of "Cookworks Signature Breadmaker". The same menu, LCD, Buttons.



enter image description here










share|improve this question




















  • 8





    There's more than one type of dried yeast. There's active dry yeast and instant dry yeast, and there's a difference.

    – GdD
    May 14 at 14:54






  • 1





    @GdD : but would it have even risen with the wrong yeast? This is almost behaving more like a souffle ... so maybe insufficient gluten development? Or it's not actually heating correctly to cook the bread (but the picture looks to be a shell of crust and a fallen middle? Or is that the pan on the outside?)

    – Joe
    May 14 at 15:06






  • 4





    It can make a big difference. Active dry yeast is slower acting than instant yeast. If you use instant yeast or too much active yeast the dough rises too quickly and can collapse.

    – GdD
    May 14 at 15:09






  • 2





    I agree with @GdD, the dough has risen too fast. Make sure that you are using a bread machine recipe - not all bread recipes survive the transition to a bread machine, often machine breads need less yeast, and more gluten. Actually I am going to make this into a more comprehensive answer.

    – bob1
    May 14 at 15:31








  • 1





    Are you using all purpose flour, cake flour or bread flour? Specialized bread flours (aka strong flours) have a much higher gluten content and so are more resistant to collapsing.

    – Vality
    May 14 at 18:25














9












9








9








I really need some help!
Every time I try to bake some bread in my bread maker, the bread rises at first but just when cooking process starts and the device increases the heat, the dough fall down!
I tried several recipes with white bread, french bread, whole wheat bread with various amounts but always this happens.



My device is Even Baker XBM 1029S. There is not much info about this model but it seems to be a clone of "Cookworks Signature Breadmaker". The same menu, LCD, Buttons.



enter image description here










share|improve this question
















I really need some help!
Every time I try to bake some bread in my bread maker, the bread rises at first but just when cooking process starts and the device increases the heat, the dough fall down!
I tried several recipes with white bread, french bread, whole wheat bread with various amounts but always this happens.



My device is Even Baker XBM 1029S. There is not much info about this model but it seems to be a clone of "Cookworks Signature Breadmaker". The same menu, LCD, Buttons.



enter image description here







bread






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited May 14 at 12:28







rostamiani

















asked May 14 at 11:49









rostamianirostamiani

14614




14614








  • 8





    There's more than one type of dried yeast. There's active dry yeast and instant dry yeast, and there's a difference.

    – GdD
    May 14 at 14:54






  • 1





    @GdD : but would it have even risen with the wrong yeast? This is almost behaving more like a souffle ... so maybe insufficient gluten development? Or it's not actually heating correctly to cook the bread (but the picture looks to be a shell of crust and a fallen middle? Or is that the pan on the outside?)

    – Joe
    May 14 at 15:06






  • 4





    It can make a big difference. Active dry yeast is slower acting than instant yeast. If you use instant yeast or too much active yeast the dough rises too quickly and can collapse.

    – GdD
    May 14 at 15:09






  • 2





    I agree with @GdD, the dough has risen too fast. Make sure that you are using a bread machine recipe - not all bread recipes survive the transition to a bread machine, often machine breads need less yeast, and more gluten. Actually I am going to make this into a more comprehensive answer.

    – bob1
    May 14 at 15:31








  • 1





    Are you using all purpose flour, cake flour or bread flour? Specialized bread flours (aka strong flours) have a much higher gluten content and so are more resistant to collapsing.

    – Vality
    May 14 at 18:25














  • 8





    There's more than one type of dried yeast. There's active dry yeast and instant dry yeast, and there's a difference.

    – GdD
    May 14 at 14:54






  • 1





    @GdD : but would it have even risen with the wrong yeast? This is almost behaving more like a souffle ... so maybe insufficient gluten development? Or it's not actually heating correctly to cook the bread (but the picture looks to be a shell of crust and a fallen middle? Or is that the pan on the outside?)

    – Joe
    May 14 at 15:06






  • 4





    It can make a big difference. Active dry yeast is slower acting than instant yeast. If you use instant yeast or too much active yeast the dough rises too quickly and can collapse.

    – GdD
    May 14 at 15:09






  • 2





    I agree with @GdD, the dough has risen too fast. Make sure that you are using a bread machine recipe - not all bread recipes survive the transition to a bread machine, often machine breads need less yeast, and more gluten. Actually I am going to make this into a more comprehensive answer.

    – bob1
    May 14 at 15:31








  • 1





    Are you using all purpose flour, cake flour or bread flour? Specialized bread flours (aka strong flours) have a much higher gluten content and so are more resistant to collapsing.

    – Vality
    May 14 at 18:25








8




8





There's more than one type of dried yeast. There's active dry yeast and instant dry yeast, and there's a difference.

– GdD
May 14 at 14:54





There's more than one type of dried yeast. There's active dry yeast and instant dry yeast, and there's a difference.

– GdD
May 14 at 14:54




1




1





@GdD : but would it have even risen with the wrong yeast? This is almost behaving more like a souffle ... so maybe insufficient gluten development? Or it's not actually heating correctly to cook the bread (but the picture looks to be a shell of crust and a fallen middle? Or is that the pan on the outside?)

– Joe
May 14 at 15:06





@GdD : but would it have even risen with the wrong yeast? This is almost behaving more like a souffle ... so maybe insufficient gluten development? Or it's not actually heating correctly to cook the bread (but the picture looks to be a shell of crust and a fallen middle? Or is that the pan on the outside?)

– Joe
May 14 at 15:06




4




4





It can make a big difference. Active dry yeast is slower acting than instant yeast. If you use instant yeast or too much active yeast the dough rises too quickly and can collapse.

– GdD
May 14 at 15:09





It can make a big difference. Active dry yeast is slower acting than instant yeast. If you use instant yeast or too much active yeast the dough rises too quickly and can collapse.

– GdD
May 14 at 15:09




2




2





I agree with @GdD, the dough has risen too fast. Make sure that you are using a bread machine recipe - not all bread recipes survive the transition to a bread machine, often machine breads need less yeast, and more gluten. Actually I am going to make this into a more comprehensive answer.

– bob1
May 14 at 15:31







I agree with @GdD, the dough has risen too fast. Make sure that you are using a bread machine recipe - not all bread recipes survive the transition to a bread machine, often machine breads need less yeast, and more gluten. Actually I am going to make this into a more comprehensive answer.

– bob1
May 14 at 15:31






1




1





Are you using all purpose flour, cake flour or bread flour? Specialized bread flours (aka strong flours) have a much higher gluten content and so are more resistant to collapsing.

– Vality
May 14 at 18:25





Are you using all purpose flour, cake flour or bread flour? Specialized bread flours (aka strong flours) have a much higher gluten content and so are more resistant to collapsing.

– Vality
May 14 at 18:25










4 Answers
4






active

oldest

votes


















10














I would first check on the type of flour I am using. To produce breads, always use flour that contains the highest protein count. It is this protein that produces gluten, and the more of this protein the stronger the gluten. This can be called a multitude of things, from 'Strong Flour', to 'Baker's Flour', to 'Best For Bread'.



Another thing you might want to do is check your mixing times. If your dough is undermixed, the gluten will not be strong enough to properly expand and hold structure from the CO2 produced by the yeast. Likewise, if the dough is overmixed you can see the same problem.



just a couple of things to start.



EDIT: you don't mention what type of flour you are using at all... If you aren't at least using a 50% mix of wheat flour, you aren't going to get proper rise as wheat flour is the only type that contains 'gluten'. Even when you buy 'whole wheat bread', this is usually a mixture of flours.






share|improve this answer


























  • In the US, it's labeled 'bread flour'. (as opposed to 'cake flour' or 'all purpose flour' ... but even all purpose I wouldn't have suspected to collapse like that ... you'd almost need a non-wheat flour with no gluten at all.)

    – Joe
    May 14 at 15:10











  • I totally agree with the above. Because OP mentioned they tried french bread, I made the assumption that they were using wheat flour. I will edit my comment.

    – mrwienerdog
    May 14 at 15:15






  • 1





    I would add that you can buy gluten to add to the flour if necessary - some recipes call for additional gluten, and it does help in my experience.

    – bob1
    May 14 at 15:28






  • 4





    @Joe It really depends on the country as well. In Canada, for example, our "All Purpose" flour is frequently around 12-13% protein, which in some places would be a rather strong bread flour. Oddly, often even within the same brand the "bread" flour really isn't much stronger than the all-purpose (13% vs 14%, etc). We just happen to grow really strong wheat here. Even our cake flours are on the strong side of 10% protein.

    – J...
    May 14 at 17:32





















9














In addition to what @mrwienerdog has suggested...



Bread machine recipes are a distinct branch of bread recipes. Most bread recipes that you find on the internet and in cookery books assume that you are making by hand (or at least using a mixer to knead the dough). Bread machines mix and knead the dough much less thoroughly than is needed compared to "hand" kneading. This is a result of the need to use as small a paddle as possible (so you don't destroy the loaf when removing), but results in a loose texture to the dough if no additional gluten is added, or a low gluten flour is used. The dough will then rise fast, and create a very weak texture which will collapse when baked.



Other possible causes are:




  1. too much liquid - be careful when measuring your liquid, follow the recipe as closely as possible, and make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients.

  2. (as per comments above) Instant yeast vs active dry yeast - Instant are stronger and will cause more rapid rising, cut back on the yeast if you have instant.

  3. Adding yeast at the wrong point - make sure the yeast sits on top of the flour and is not in contact with the water before mixing. If you add it early on and the yeast is sitting in water, it will start to grow and your loaf will over-rise, especially if you are using a delay timer for an overnight bake for example.


I bake both by hand and (now) use a bread machine, and ended up with a few loaves that looked like yours, and had other problems for the first few loaves when switching to the machine. I found that the best way to learn exactly what were the problems with the machine, was to open the machine and have a look and feel of the dough during the kneading process. This, along with a bit of experimentation in terms of liquid, gluten and other ingredients means that we now get nice consistent loaves. The key I found was to make sure that the proportions of ingredients are very close to the recipes.



Typically for a 1.5 lb loaf I use:



1 cup water (add milk powder to make milk, or substitute room-temp milk)
1 tsp salt
1 tsp sugar
2 tbsp oil
3 cups bread flour (1 c + 2 tbsp whole-wheat, 2 c white for whole-wheat)
3 tsp gluten (6 for whole-wheat)
1.25 or less tsp active dry yeast.





share|improve this answer





















  • 1





    "make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients" - not where I come from (besides the fact that flour should be measured by weight whenever possible). There are reasons why dry measuring cups are made differently from wet ones even if the marked volumes are the same. A dry cup is meant to be filled to the top so it can be leveled and a wet measuring cup has extra height above the top line to prevent unwanted spillage - making it impossible to level dry ingredients.

    – Dennis Williamson
    May 14 at 22:29






  • 2





    Yes, true in general - however in my experience (and based on the bread books I have) the flour and water are usually measured in cups rather than weight, and a simple shake of the cup will settle the flour to a level that's pretty accurate. It's the ratio that's important mostly. Also, in my admittedly small experience with bread machines - they come with a cup that is used to measure all ingredients - switching between different cups can be enough to get the ratios out of proportion.

    – bob1
    May 15 at 2:25






  • 3





    "make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients" - alternatively weigh your ingredients carefully and use a recipe that specifies weight. That would be the default in Europe.

    – abligh
    May 15 at 5:30






  • 2





    the flour and water are usually measured in cups rather than weight ... in the US. In Europe the concept of "cup" does not exist. We have metric weights and volumes only.

    – WoJ
    May 15 at 9:04











  • @WoJ, The UK uses cups, as do Aus, NZ and many other Commonwealth countries, which is where my experience comes from. Admittedly, cups in those countries are 250 ml, so easy metric conversions. US is 240 ml, but can be converted in terms of tablespoons (16), and fluid oz etc, which the Americans seem to love - I still don't get them having been in the US for 3 years.

    – bob1
    May 15 at 13:50



















2














This is a hard problem to diagnose. There are many things that can cause this, and trying to figure out which it is (or even if it's the same each time) can cause you to tear out your hair in frustration.



Even so, they all basically boil down to the bread rising too fast and then collapsing. (Sure. And all my money problems are caused by expenditures exceeding income. But how do I solve that? If I just stop paying my employees, I've really cut expenditures, but I won't have any income at all!)



One possible problem is too much liquid. The water turns to steam, puffing up the bread in the oven (or the bread machine), but then there isn't enough support structure underneath and it collapses.
Similarly, if there's too much yeast, or it grows too fast because of too much sugar, or too little salt (part of what the salt does is inhibit yeast growth), or if you were on timer and you didn't keep the yeast out of the liquid, or the temperature was too perfect, or who knows what, the little creatures just grow too fast and give off too much carbon dioxide, which puffs up the bread, but there isn't enough support structure underneath to support it, and it collapses.



It's somewhat interesting that the collapse happens early in the process in a bread machine (sunken top) and a little later in hand kneading and oven baking (mushroom top with huge air bubble). Or maybe that's just my experience.



One possibility is that your flour has absorbed moisture from the air. I now start all my bread recipes with 1/4 cup less liquid than the recipe calls for and find that I am equally likely to add flour or water to get to the right dough consistency. And after years of using a bread machine, I will say that it is far easier to judge the consistency of dough by feel (kneading) than by sight and sound (bread machine).



Edit: I forgot to mention: bread flour (high gluten content) really does make a difference. If a recipe calls for bread flour, use that. If it calls for all purpose flour, it may or may not really need it. (Sausage buns, dinner rolls, hamburger buns are all better [softer] with all purpose flour. All the recipes in Charel Scheele's book, Old World Breads [not a bread machine cookbook, but the recipes are easy to adapt], call for all purpose flour, but I haven't found any that seem to need it and only a few [holiday breads] that seem to prefer it.) I haven't yet found a recipe that required additional gluten if you're already using bread flour, although I've found quite a few that called for it. Maybe I've just been lucky and it's the difference of environment, or maybe the people who wrote those recipes are just health nuts. (Yes, I realize a nut is someone who forcefully expresses an opinion I don't wholeheartedly agree with.)






share|improve this answer

































    1














    I have no experience with bread machines, but plenty of experience with making bread by hand, and using a mixer with a dough hook.



    Bread typically falls if you haven't baked it enough, if you haven't kneaded it enough, or if you haven't used strong flour.



    It's very difficult to diagnose the issue you're facing without more info, but here's my best educated guess... I doubt the bread is being under baked, or not kneaded enough, because you're using a machine that is designed to do it properly, so I'd bet that you're not using strong flour.



    Strong flour is suitable for this style of bread making because it contains enough gluten to provide a structure for the bread that doesn't allow air to escape. If you don't have enough gluten in your dough, or don't work the gluten enough, air will escape from your dough and your bread will fall.






    share|improve this answer


























    • I disagree with the generalizations you make here. Strong flour is not "the correct type of flour" for bread. It is the type of flour which is preferred for bread in the anglo-saxon baking tradition. It is a more recent introduction to Western Europe, while many countries farther East have great bread baking traditions without ever having produced strong flour. Ukraine, Bulgaria, Turkey, etc. bake perfect leavened breads without it. I don't know what caused this one case - but your implication that everybody should only bake with strong flour is incorrect.

      – rumtscho
      May 16 at 8:47











    • @rumtscho, apologies, I will reword my answer. I didn't intend to make that implication, I was trying to express that they could be using an unsuitable flour for this specific scenario. I was not trying to make a sweeping generalisation.

      – Doctor Jones
      May 16 at 9:11











    • Thank you for editing, it is indeed much better now.

      – rumtscho
      May 16 at 9:59












    Your Answer








    StackExchange.ready(function() {
    var channelOptions = {
    tags: "".split(" "),
    id: "49"
    };
    initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

    StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
    // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
    if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
    StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
    createEditor();
    });
    }
    else {
    createEditor();
    }
    });

    function createEditor() {
    StackExchange.prepareEditor({
    heartbeatType: 'answer',
    autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
    convertImagesToLinks: false,
    noModals: true,
    showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
    reputationToPostImages: null,
    bindNavPrevention: true,
    postfix: "",
    imageUploader: {
    brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
    contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
    allowUrls: true
    },
    noCode: true, onDemand: true,
    discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
    ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
    });


    }
    });














    draft saved

    draft discarded


















    StackExchange.ready(
    function () {
    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fcooking.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f98991%2fmy-bread-in-my-bread-maker-rises-and-then-falls-down-just-after-cooking-starts%23new-answer', 'question_page');
    }
    );

    Post as a guest















    Required, but never shown

























    4 Answers
    4






    active

    oldest

    votes








    4 Answers
    4






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes









    10














    I would first check on the type of flour I am using. To produce breads, always use flour that contains the highest protein count. It is this protein that produces gluten, and the more of this protein the stronger the gluten. This can be called a multitude of things, from 'Strong Flour', to 'Baker's Flour', to 'Best For Bread'.



    Another thing you might want to do is check your mixing times. If your dough is undermixed, the gluten will not be strong enough to properly expand and hold structure from the CO2 produced by the yeast. Likewise, if the dough is overmixed you can see the same problem.



    just a couple of things to start.



    EDIT: you don't mention what type of flour you are using at all... If you aren't at least using a 50% mix of wheat flour, you aren't going to get proper rise as wheat flour is the only type that contains 'gluten'. Even when you buy 'whole wheat bread', this is usually a mixture of flours.






    share|improve this answer


























    • In the US, it's labeled 'bread flour'. (as opposed to 'cake flour' or 'all purpose flour' ... but even all purpose I wouldn't have suspected to collapse like that ... you'd almost need a non-wheat flour with no gluten at all.)

      – Joe
      May 14 at 15:10











    • I totally agree with the above. Because OP mentioned they tried french bread, I made the assumption that they were using wheat flour. I will edit my comment.

      – mrwienerdog
      May 14 at 15:15






    • 1





      I would add that you can buy gluten to add to the flour if necessary - some recipes call for additional gluten, and it does help in my experience.

      – bob1
      May 14 at 15:28






    • 4





      @Joe It really depends on the country as well. In Canada, for example, our "All Purpose" flour is frequently around 12-13% protein, which in some places would be a rather strong bread flour. Oddly, often even within the same brand the "bread" flour really isn't much stronger than the all-purpose (13% vs 14%, etc). We just happen to grow really strong wheat here. Even our cake flours are on the strong side of 10% protein.

      – J...
      May 14 at 17:32


















    10














    I would first check on the type of flour I am using. To produce breads, always use flour that contains the highest protein count. It is this protein that produces gluten, and the more of this protein the stronger the gluten. This can be called a multitude of things, from 'Strong Flour', to 'Baker's Flour', to 'Best For Bread'.



    Another thing you might want to do is check your mixing times. If your dough is undermixed, the gluten will not be strong enough to properly expand and hold structure from the CO2 produced by the yeast. Likewise, if the dough is overmixed you can see the same problem.



    just a couple of things to start.



    EDIT: you don't mention what type of flour you are using at all... If you aren't at least using a 50% mix of wheat flour, you aren't going to get proper rise as wheat flour is the only type that contains 'gluten'. Even when you buy 'whole wheat bread', this is usually a mixture of flours.






    share|improve this answer


























    • In the US, it's labeled 'bread flour'. (as opposed to 'cake flour' or 'all purpose flour' ... but even all purpose I wouldn't have suspected to collapse like that ... you'd almost need a non-wheat flour with no gluten at all.)

      – Joe
      May 14 at 15:10











    • I totally agree with the above. Because OP mentioned they tried french bread, I made the assumption that they were using wheat flour. I will edit my comment.

      – mrwienerdog
      May 14 at 15:15






    • 1





      I would add that you can buy gluten to add to the flour if necessary - some recipes call for additional gluten, and it does help in my experience.

      – bob1
      May 14 at 15:28






    • 4





      @Joe It really depends on the country as well. In Canada, for example, our "All Purpose" flour is frequently around 12-13% protein, which in some places would be a rather strong bread flour. Oddly, often even within the same brand the "bread" flour really isn't much stronger than the all-purpose (13% vs 14%, etc). We just happen to grow really strong wheat here. Even our cake flours are on the strong side of 10% protein.

      – J...
      May 14 at 17:32
















    10












    10








    10







    I would first check on the type of flour I am using. To produce breads, always use flour that contains the highest protein count. It is this protein that produces gluten, and the more of this protein the stronger the gluten. This can be called a multitude of things, from 'Strong Flour', to 'Baker's Flour', to 'Best For Bread'.



    Another thing you might want to do is check your mixing times. If your dough is undermixed, the gluten will not be strong enough to properly expand and hold structure from the CO2 produced by the yeast. Likewise, if the dough is overmixed you can see the same problem.



    just a couple of things to start.



    EDIT: you don't mention what type of flour you are using at all... If you aren't at least using a 50% mix of wheat flour, you aren't going to get proper rise as wheat flour is the only type that contains 'gluten'. Even when you buy 'whole wheat bread', this is usually a mixture of flours.






    share|improve this answer















    I would first check on the type of flour I am using. To produce breads, always use flour that contains the highest protein count. It is this protein that produces gluten, and the more of this protein the stronger the gluten. This can be called a multitude of things, from 'Strong Flour', to 'Baker's Flour', to 'Best For Bread'.



    Another thing you might want to do is check your mixing times. If your dough is undermixed, the gluten will not be strong enough to properly expand and hold structure from the CO2 produced by the yeast. Likewise, if the dough is overmixed you can see the same problem.



    just a couple of things to start.



    EDIT: you don't mention what type of flour you are using at all... If you aren't at least using a 50% mix of wheat flour, you aren't going to get proper rise as wheat flour is the only type that contains 'gluten'. Even when you buy 'whole wheat bread', this is usually a mixture of flours.







    share|improve this answer














    share|improve this answer



    share|improve this answer








    edited May 14 at 15:17

























    answered May 14 at 15:04









    mrwienerdogmrwienerdog

    5,57111931




    5,57111931













    • In the US, it's labeled 'bread flour'. (as opposed to 'cake flour' or 'all purpose flour' ... but even all purpose I wouldn't have suspected to collapse like that ... you'd almost need a non-wheat flour with no gluten at all.)

      – Joe
      May 14 at 15:10











    • I totally agree with the above. Because OP mentioned they tried french bread, I made the assumption that they were using wheat flour. I will edit my comment.

      – mrwienerdog
      May 14 at 15:15






    • 1





      I would add that you can buy gluten to add to the flour if necessary - some recipes call for additional gluten, and it does help in my experience.

      – bob1
      May 14 at 15:28






    • 4





      @Joe It really depends on the country as well. In Canada, for example, our "All Purpose" flour is frequently around 12-13% protein, which in some places would be a rather strong bread flour. Oddly, often even within the same brand the "bread" flour really isn't much stronger than the all-purpose (13% vs 14%, etc). We just happen to grow really strong wheat here. Even our cake flours are on the strong side of 10% protein.

      – J...
      May 14 at 17:32





















    • In the US, it's labeled 'bread flour'. (as opposed to 'cake flour' or 'all purpose flour' ... but even all purpose I wouldn't have suspected to collapse like that ... you'd almost need a non-wheat flour with no gluten at all.)

      – Joe
      May 14 at 15:10











    • I totally agree with the above. Because OP mentioned they tried french bread, I made the assumption that they were using wheat flour. I will edit my comment.

      – mrwienerdog
      May 14 at 15:15






    • 1





      I would add that you can buy gluten to add to the flour if necessary - some recipes call for additional gluten, and it does help in my experience.

      – bob1
      May 14 at 15:28






    • 4





      @Joe It really depends on the country as well. In Canada, for example, our "All Purpose" flour is frequently around 12-13% protein, which in some places would be a rather strong bread flour. Oddly, often even within the same brand the "bread" flour really isn't much stronger than the all-purpose (13% vs 14%, etc). We just happen to grow really strong wheat here. Even our cake flours are on the strong side of 10% protein.

      – J...
      May 14 at 17:32



















    In the US, it's labeled 'bread flour'. (as opposed to 'cake flour' or 'all purpose flour' ... but even all purpose I wouldn't have suspected to collapse like that ... you'd almost need a non-wheat flour with no gluten at all.)

    – Joe
    May 14 at 15:10





    In the US, it's labeled 'bread flour'. (as opposed to 'cake flour' or 'all purpose flour' ... but even all purpose I wouldn't have suspected to collapse like that ... you'd almost need a non-wheat flour with no gluten at all.)

    – Joe
    May 14 at 15:10













    I totally agree with the above. Because OP mentioned they tried french bread, I made the assumption that they were using wheat flour. I will edit my comment.

    – mrwienerdog
    May 14 at 15:15





    I totally agree with the above. Because OP mentioned they tried french bread, I made the assumption that they were using wheat flour. I will edit my comment.

    – mrwienerdog
    May 14 at 15:15




    1




    1





    I would add that you can buy gluten to add to the flour if necessary - some recipes call for additional gluten, and it does help in my experience.

    – bob1
    May 14 at 15:28





    I would add that you can buy gluten to add to the flour if necessary - some recipes call for additional gluten, and it does help in my experience.

    – bob1
    May 14 at 15:28




    4




    4





    @Joe It really depends on the country as well. In Canada, for example, our "All Purpose" flour is frequently around 12-13% protein, which in some places would be a rather strong bread flour. Oddly, often even within the same brand the "bread" flour really isn't much stronger than the all-purpose (13% vs 14%, etc). We just happen to grow really strong wheat here. Even our cake flours are on the strong side of 10% protein.

    – J...
    May 14 at 17:32







    @Joe It really depends on the country as well. In Canada, for example, our "All Purpose" flour is frequently around 12-13% protein, which in some places would be a rather strong bread flour. Oddly, often even within the same brand the "bread" flour really isn't much stronger than the all-purpose (13% vs 14%, etc). We just happen to grow really strong wheat here. Even our cake flours are on the strong side of 10% protein.

    – J...
    May 14 at 17:32















    9














    In addition to what @mrwienerdog has suggested...



    Bread machine recipes are a distinct branch of bread recipes. Most bread recipes that you find on the internet and in cookery books assume that you are making by hand (or at least using a mixer to knead the dough). Bread machines mix and knead the dough much less thoroughly than is needed compared to "hand" kneading. This is a result of the need to use as small a paddle as possible (so you don't destroy the loaf when removing), but results in a loose texture to the dough if no additional gluten is added, or a low gluten flour is used. The dough will then rise fast, and create a very weak texture which will collapse when baked.



    Other possible causes are:




    1. too much liquid - be careful when measuring your liquid, follow the recipe as closely as possible, and make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients.

    2. (as per comments above) Instant yeast vs active dry yeast - Instant are stronger and will cause more rapid rising, cut back on the yeast if you have instant.

    3. Adding yeast at the wrong point - make sure the yeast sits on top of the flour and is not in contact with the water before mixing. If you add it early on and the yeast is sitting in water, it will start to grow and your loaf will over-rise, especially if you are using a delay timer for an overnight bake for example.


    I bake both by hand and (now) use a bread machine, and ended up with a few loaves that looked like yours, and had other problems for the first few loaves when switching to the machine. I found that the best way to learn exactly what were the problems with the machine, was to open the machine and have a look and feel of the dough during the kneading process. This, along with a bit of experimentation in terms of liquid, gluten and other ingredients means that we now get nice consistent loaves. The key I found was to make sure that the proportions of ingredients are very close to the recipes.



    Typically for a 1.5 lb loaf I use:



    1 cup water (add milk powder to make milk, or substitute room-temp milk)
    1 tsp salt
    1 tsp sugar
    2 tbsp oil
    3 cups bread flour (1 c + 2 tbsp whole-wheat, 2 c white for whole-wheat)
    3 tsp gluten (6 for whole-wheat)
    1.25 or less tsp active dry yeast.





    share|improve this answer





















    • 1





      "make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients" - not where I come from (besides the fact that flour should be measured by weight whenever possible). There are reasons why dry measuring cups are made differently from wet ones even if the marked volumes are the same. A dry cup is meant to be filled to the top so it can be leveled and a wet measuring cup has extra height above the top line to prevent unwanted spillage - making it impossible to level dry ingredients.

      – Dennis Williamson
      May 14 at 22:29






    • 2





      Yes, true in general - however in my experience (and based on the bread books I have) the flour and water are usually measured in cups rather than weight, and a simple shake of the cup will settle the flour to a level that's pretty accurate. It's the ratio that's important mostly. Also, in my admittedly small experience with bread machines - they come with a cup that is used to measure all ingredients - switching between different cups can be enough to get the ratios out of proportion.

      – bob1
      May 15 at 2:25






    • 3





      "make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients" - alternatively weigh your ingredients carefully and use a recipe that specifies weight. That would be the default in Europe.

      – abligh
      May 15 at 5:30






    • 2





      the flour and water are usually measured in cups rather than weight ... in the US. In Europe the concept of "cup" does not exist. We have metric weights and volumes only.

      – WoJ
      May 15 at 9:04











    • @WoJ, The UK uses cups, as do Aus, NZ and many other Commonwealth countries, which is where my experience comes from. Admittedly, cups in those countries are 250 ml, so easy metric conversions. US is 240 ml, but can be converted in terms of tablespoons (16), and fluid oz etc, which the Americans seem to love - I still don't get them having been in the US for 3 years.

      – bob1
      May 15 at 13:50
















    9














    In addition to what @mrwienerdog has suggested...



    Bread machine recipes are a distinct branch of bread recipes. Most bread recipes that you find on the internet and in cookery books assume that you are making by hand (or at least using a mixer to knead the dough). Bread machines mix and knead the dough much less thoroughly than is needed compared to "hand" kneading. This is a result of the need to use as small a paddle as possible (so you don't destroy the loaf when removing), but results in a loose texture to the dough if no additional gluten is added, or a low gluten flour is used. The dough will then rise fast, and create a very weak texture which will collapse when baked.



    Other possible causes are:




    1. too much liquid - be careful when measuring your liquid, follow the recipe as closely as possible, and make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients.

    2. (as per comments above) Instant yeast vs active dry yeast - Instant are stronger and will cause more rapid rising, cut back on the yeast if you have instant.

    3. Adding yeast at the wrong point - make sure the yeast sits on top of the flour and is not in contact with the water before mixing. If you add it early on and the yeast is sitting in water, it will start to grow and your loaf will over-rise, especially if you are using a delay timer for an overnight bake for example.


    I bake both by hand and (now) use a bread machine, and ended up with a few loaves that looked like yours, and had other problems for the first few loaves when switching to the machine. I found that the best way to learn exactly what were the problems with the machine, was to open the machine and have a look and feel of the dough during the kneading process. This, along with a bit of experimentation in terms of liquid, gluten and other ingredients means that we now get nice consistent loaves. The key I found was to make sure that the proportions of ingredients are very close to the recipes.



    Typically for a 1.5 lb loaf I use:



    1 cup water (add milk powder to make milk, or substitute room-temp milk)
    1 tsp salt
    1 tsp sugar
    2 tbsp oil
    3 cups bread flour (1 c + 2 tbsp whole-wheat, 2 c white for whole-wheat)
    3 tsp gluten (6 for whole-wheat)
    1.25 or less tsp active dry yeast.





    share|improve this answer





















    • 1





      "make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients" - not where I come from (besides the fact that flour should be measured by weight whenever possible). There are reasons why dry measuring cups are made differently from wet ones even if the marked volumes are the same. A dry cup is meant to be filled to the top so it can be leveled and a wet measuring cup has extra height above the top line to prevent unwanted spillage - making it impossible to level dry ingredients.

      – Dennis Williamson
      May 14 at 22:29






    • 2





      Yes, true in general - however in my experience (and based on the bread books I have) the flour and water are usually measured in cups rather than weight, and a simple shake of the cup will settle the flour to a level that's pretty accurate. It's the ratio that's important mostly. Also, in my admittedly small experience with bread machines - they come with a cup that is used to measure all ingredients - switching between different cups can be enough to get the ratios out of proportion.

      – bob1
      May 15 at 2:25






    • 3





      "make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients" - alternatively weigh your ingredients carefully and use a recipe that specifies weight. That would be the default in Europe.

      – abligh
      May 15 at 5:30






    • 2





      the flour and water are usually measured in cups rather than weight ... in the US. In Europe the concept of "cup" does not exist. We have metric weights and volumes only.

      – WoJ
      May 15 at 9:04











    • @WoJ, The UK uses cups, as do Aus, NZ and many other Commonwealth countries, which is where my experience comes from. Admittedly, cups in those countries are 250 ml, so easy metric conversions. US is 240 ml, but can be converted in terms of tablespoons (16), and fluid oz etc, which the Americans seem to love - I still don't get them having been in the US for 3 years.

      – bob1
      May 15 at 13:50














    9












    9








    9







    In addition to what @mrwienerdog has suggested...



    Bread machine recipes are a distinct branch of bread recipes. Most bread recipes that you find on the internet and in cookery books assume that you are making by hand (or at least using a mixer to knead the dough). Bread machines mix and knead the dough much less thoroughly than is needed compared to "hand" kneading. This is a result of the need to use as small a paddle as possible (so you don't destroy the loaf when removing), but results in a loose texture to the dough if no additional gluten is added, or a low gluten flour is used. The dough will then rise fast, and create a very weak texture which will collapse when baked.



    Other possible causes are:




    1. too much liquid - be careful when measuring your liquid, follow the recipe as closely as possible, and make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients.

    2. (as per comments above) Instant yeast vs active dry yeast - Instant are stronger and will cause more rapid rising, cut back on the yeast if you have instant.

    3. Adding yeast at the wrong point - make sure the yeast sits on top of the flour and is not in contact with the water before mixing. If you add it early on and the yeast is sitting in water, it will start to grow and your loaf will over-rise, especially if you are using a delay timer for an overnight bake for example.


    I bake both by hand and (now) use a bread machine, and ended up with a few loaves that looked like yours, and had other problems for the first few loaves when switching to the machine. I found that the best way to learn exactly what were the problems with the machine, was to open the machine and have a look and feel of the dough during the kneading process. This, along with a bit of experimentation in terms of liquid, gluten and other ingredients means that we now get nice consistent loaves. The key I found was to make sure that the proportions of ingredients are very close to the recipes.



    Typically for a 1.5 lb loaf I use:



    1 cup water (add milk powder to make milk, or substitute room-temp milk)
    1 tsp salt
    1 tsp sugar
    2 tbsp oil
    3 cups bread flour (1 c + 2 tbsp whole-wheat, 2 c white for whole-wheat)
    3 tsp gluten (6 for whole-wheat)
    1.25 or less tsp active dry yeast.





    share|improve this answer















    In addition to what @mrwienerdog has suggested...



    Bread machine recipes are a distinct branch of bread recipes. Most bread recipes that you find on the internet and in cookery books assume that you are making by hand (or at least using a mixer to knead the dough). Bread machines mix and knead the dough much less thoroughly than is needed compared to "hand" kneading. This is a result of the need to use as small a paddle as possible (so you don't destroy the loaf when removing), but results in a loose texture to the dough if no additional gluten is added, or a low gluten flour is used. The dough will then rise fast, and create a very weak texture which will collapse when baked.



    Other possible causes are:




    1. too much liquid - be careful when measuring your liquid, follow the recipe as closely as possible, and make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients.

    2. (as per comments above) Instant yeast vs active dry yeast - Instant are stronger and will cause more rapid rising, cut back on the yeast if you have instant.

    3. Adding yeast at the wrong point - make sure the yeast sits on top of the flour and is not in contact with the water before mixing. If you add it early on and the yeast is sitting in water, it will start to grow and your loaf will over-rise, especially if you are using a delay timer for an overnight bake for example.


    I bake both by hand and (now) use a bread machine, and ended up with a few loaves that looked like yours, and had other problems for the first few loaves when switching to the machine. I found that the best way to learn exactly what were the problems with the machine, was to open the machine and have a look and feel of the dough during the kneading process. This, along with a bit of experimentation in terms of liquid, gluten and other ingredients means that we now get nice consistent loaves. The key I found was to make sure that the proportions of ingredients are very close to the recipes.



    Typically for a 1.5 lb loaf I use:



    1 cup water (add milk powder to make milk, or substitute room-temp milk)
    1 tsp salt
    1 tsp sugar
    2 tbsp oil
    3 cups bread flour (1 c + 2 tbsp whole-wheat, 2 c white for whole-wheat)
    3 tsp gluten (6 for whole-wheat)
    1.25 or less tsp active dry yeast.






    share|improve this answer














    share|improve this answer



    share|improve this answer








    edited May 14 at 16:01

























    answered May 14 at 15:55









    bob1bob1

    1,768211




    1,768211








    • 1





      "make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients" - not where I come from (besides the fact that flour should be measured by weight whenever possible). There are reasons why dry measuring cups are made differently from wet ones even if the marked volumes are the same. A dry cup is meant to be filled to the top so it can be leveled and a wet measuring cup has extra height above the top line to prevent unwanted spillage - making it impossible to level dry ingredients.

      – Dennis Williamson
      May 14 at 22:29






    • 2





      Yes, true in general - however in my experience (and based on the bread books I have) the flour and water are usually measured in cups rather than weight, and a simple shake of the cup will settle the flour to a level that's pretty accurate. It's the ratio that's important mostly. Also, in my admittedly small experience with bread machines - they come with a cup that is used to measure all ingredients - switching between different cups can be enough to get the ratios out of proportion.

      – bob1
      May 15 at 2:25






    • 3





      "make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients" - alternatively weigh your ingredients carefully and use a recipe that specifies weight. That would be the default in Europe.

      – abligh
      May 15 at 5:30






    • 2





      the flour and water are usually measured in cups rather than weight ... in the US. In Europe the concept of "cup" does not exist. We have metric weights and volumes only.

      – WoJ
      May 15 at 9:04











    • @WoJ, The UK uses cups, as do Aus, NZ and many other Commonwealth countries, which is where my experience comes from. Admittedly, cups in those countries are 250 ml, so easy metric conversions. US is 240 ml, but can be converted in terms of tablespoons (16), and fluid oz etc, which the Americans seem to love - I still don't get them having been in the US for 3 years.

      – bob1
      May 15 at 13:50














    • 1





      "make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients" - not where I come from (besides the fact that flour should be measured by weight whenever possible). There are reasons why dry measuring cups are made differently from wet ones even if the marked volumes are the same. A dry cup is meant to be filled to the top so it can be leveled and a wet measuring cup has extra height above the top line to prevent unwanted spillage - making it impossible to level dry ingredients.

      – Dennis Williamson
      May 14 at 22:29






    • 2





      Yes, true in general - however in my experience (and based on the bread books I have) the flour and water are usually measured in cups rather than weight, and a simple shake of the cup will settle the flour to a level that's pretty accurate. It's the ratio that's important mostly. Also, in my admittedly small experience with bread machines - they come with a cup that is used to measure all ingredients - switching between different cups can be enough to get the ratios out of proportion.

      – bob1
      May 15 at 2:25






    • 3





      "make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients" - alternatively weigh your ingredients carefully and use a recipe that specifies weight. That would be the default in Europe.

      – abligh
      May 15 at 5:30






    • 2





      the flour and water are usually measured in cups rather than weight ... in the US. In Europe the concept of "cup" does not exist. We have metric weights and volumes only.

      – WoJ
      May 15 at 9:04











    • @WoJ, The UK uses cups, as do Aus, NZ and many other Commonwealth countries, which is where my experience comes from. Admittedly, cups in those countries are 250 ml, so easy metric conversions. US is 240 ml, but can be converted in terms of tablespoons (16), and fluid oz etc, which the Americans seem to love - I still don't get them having been in the US for 3 years.

      – bob1
      May 15 at 13:50








    1




    1





    "make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients" - not where I come from (besides the fact that flour should be measured by weight whenever possible). There are reasons why dry measuring cups are made differently from wet ones even if the marked volumes are the same. A dry cup is meant to be filled to the top so it can be leveled and a wet measuring cup has extra height above the top line to prevent unwanted spillage - making it impossible to level dry ingredients.

    – Dennis Williamson
    May 14 at 22:29





    "make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients" - not where I come from (besides the fact that flour should be measured by weight whenever possible). There are reasons why dry measuring cups are made differently from wet ones even if the marked volumes are the same. A dry cup is meant to be filled to the top so it can be leveled and a wet measuring cup has extra height above the top line to prevent unwanted spillage - making it impossible to level dry ingredients.

    – Dennis Williamson
    May 14 at 22:29




    2




    2





    Yes, true in general - however in my experience (and based on the bread books I have) the flour and water are usually measured in cups rather than weight, and a simple shake of the cup will settle the flour to a level that's pretty accurate. It's the ratio that's important mostly. Also, in my admittedly small experience with bread machines - they come with a cup that is used to measure all ingredients - switching between different cups can be enough to get the ratios out of proportion.

    – bob1
    May 15 at 2:25





    Yes, true in general - however in my experience (and based on the bread books I have) the flour and water are usually measured in cups rather than weight, and a simple shake of the cup will settle the flour to a level that's pretty accurate. It's the ratio that's important mostly. Also, in my admittedly small experience with bread machines - they come with a cup that is used to measure all ingredients - switching between different cups can be enough to get the ratios out of proportion.

    – bob1
    May 15 at 2:25




    3




    3





    "make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients" - alternatively weigh your ingredients carefully and use a recipe that specifies weight. That would be the default in Europe.

    – abligh
    May 15 at 5:30





    "make sure that you use the same cup to measure liquid and dry ingredients" - alternatively weigh your ingredients carefully and use a recipe that specifies weight. That would be the default in Europe.

    – abligh
    May 15 at 5:30




    2




    2





    the flour and water are usually measured in cups rather than weight ... in the US. In Europe the concept of "cup" does not exist. We have metric weights and volumes only.

    – WoJ
    May 15 at 9:04





    the flour and water are usually measured in cups rather than weight ... in the US. In Europe the concept of "cup" does not exist. We have metric weights and volumes only.

    – WoJ
    May 15 at 9:04













    @WoJ, The UK uses cups, as do Aus, NZ and many other Commonwealth countries, which is where my experience comes from. Admittedly, cups in those countries are 250 ml, so easy metric conversions. US is 240 ml, but can be converted in terms of tablespoons (16), and fluid oz etc, which the Americans seem to love - I still don't get them having been in the US for 3 years.

    – bob1
    May 15 at 13:50





    @WoJ, The UK uses cups, as do Aus, NZ and many other Commonwealth countries, which is where my experience comes from. Admittedly, cups in those countries are 250 ml, so easy metric conversions. US is 240 ml, but can be converted in terms of tablespoons (16), and fluid oz etc, which the Americans seem to love - I still don't get them having been in the US for 3 years.

    – bob1
    May 15 at 13:50











    2














    This is a hard problem to diagnose. There are many things that can cause this, and trying to figure out which it is (or even if it's the same each time) can cause you to tear out your hair in frustration.



    Even so, they all basically boil down to the bread rising too fast and then collapsing. (Sure. And all my money problems are caused by expenditures exceeding income. But how do I solve that? If I just stop paying my employees, I've really cut expenditures, but I won't have any income at all!)



    One possible problem is too much liquid. The water turns to steam, puffing up the bread in the oven (or the bread machine), but then there isn't enough support structure underneath and it collapses.
    Similarly, if there's too much yeast, or it grows too fast because of too much sugar, or too little salt (part of what the salt does is inhibit yeast growth), or if you were on timer and you didn't keep the yeast out of the liquid, or the temperature was too perfect, or who knows what, the little creatures just grow too fast and give off too much carbon dioxide, which puffs up the bread, but there isn't enough support structure underneath to support it, and it collapses.



    It's somewhat interesting that the collapse happens early in the process in a bread machine (sunken top) and a little later in hand kneading and oven baking (mushroom top with huge air bubble). Or maybe that's just my experience.



    One possibility is that your flour has absorbed moisture from the air. I now start all my bread recipes with 1/4 cup less liquid than the recipe calls for and find that I am equally likely to add flour or water to get to the right dough consistency. And after years of using a bread machine, I will say that it is far easier to judge the consistency of dough by feel (kneading) than by sight and sound (bread machine).



    Edit: I forgot to mention: bread flour (high gluten content) really does make a difference. If a recipe calls for bread flour, use that. If it calls for all purpose flour, it may or may not really need it. (Sausage buns, dinner rolls, hamburger buns are all better [softer] with all purpose flour. All the recipes in Charel Scheele's book, Old World Breads [not a bread machine cookbook, but the recipes are easy to adapt], call for all purpose flour, but I haven't found any that seem to need it and only a few [holiday breads] that seem to prefer it.) I haven't yet found a recipe that required additional gluten if you're already using bread flour, although I've found quite a few that called for it. Maybe I've just been lucky and it's the difference of environment, or maybe the people who wrote those recipes are just health nuts. (Yes, I realize a nut is someone who forcefully expresses an opinion I don't wholeheartedly agree with.)






    share|improve this answer






























      2














      This is a hard problem to diagnose. There are many things that can cause this, and trying to figure out which it is (or even if it's the same each time) can cause you to tear out your hair in frustration.



      Even so, they all basically boil down to the bread rising too fast and then collapsing. (Sure. And all my money problems are caused by expenditures exceeding income. But how do I solve that? If I just stop paying my employees, I've really cut expenditures, but I won't have any income at all!)



      One possible problem is too much liquid. The water turns to steam, puffing up the bread in the oven (or the bread machine), but then there isn't enough support structure underneath and it collapses.
      Similarly, if there's too much yeast, or it grows too fast because of too much sugar, or too little salt (part of what the salt does is inhibit yeast growth), or if you were on timer and you didn't keep the yeast out of the liquid, or the temperature was too perfect, or who knows what, the little creatures just grow too fast and give off too much carbon dioxide, which puffs up the bread, but there isn't enough support structure underneath to support it, and it collapses.



      It's somewhat interesting that the collapse happens early in the process in a bread machine (sunken top) and a little later in hand kneading and oven baking (mushroom top with huge air bubble). Or maybe that's just my experience.



      One possibility is that your flour has absorbed moisture from the air. I now start all my bread recipes with 1/4 cup less liquid than the recipe calls for and find that I am equally likely to add flour or water to get to the right dough consistency. And after years of using a bread machine, I will say that it is far easier to judge the consistency of dough by feel (kneading) than by sight and sound (bread machine).



      Edit: I forgot to mention: bread flour (high gluten content) really does make a difference. If a recipe calls for bread flour, use that. If it calls for all purpose flour, it may or may not really need it. (Sausage buns, dinner rolls, hamburger buns are all better [softer] with all purpose flour. All the recipes in Charel Scheele's book, Old World Breads [not a bread machine cookbook, but the recipes are easy to adapt], call for all purpose flour, but I haven't found any that seem to need it and only a few [holiday breads] that seem to prefer it.) I haven't yet found a recipe that required additional gluten if you're already using bread flour, although I've found quite a few that called for it. Maybe I've just been lucky and it's the difference of environment, or maybe the people who wrote those recipes are just health nuts. (Yes, I realize a nut is someone who forcefully expresses an opinion I don't wholeheartedly agree with.)






      share|improve this answer




























        2












        2








        2







        This is a hard problem to diagnose. There are many things that can cause this, and trying to figure out which it is (or even if it's the same each time) can cause you to tear out your hair in frustration.



        Even so, they all basically boil down to the bread rising too fast and then collapsing. (Sure. And all my money problems are caused by expenditures exceeding income. But how do I solve that? If I just stop paying my employees, I've really cut expenditures, but I won't have any income at all!)



        One possible problem is too much liquid. The water turns to steam, puffing up the bread in the oven (or the bread machine), but then there isn't enough support structure underneath and it collapses.
        Similarly, if there's too much yeast, or it grows too fast because of too much sugar, or too little salt (part of what the salt does is inhibit yeast growth), or if you were on timer and you didn't keep the yeast out of the liquid, or the temperature was too perfect, or who knows what, the little creatures just grow too fast and give off too much carbon dioxide, which puffs up the bread, but there isn't enough support structure underneath to support it, and it collapses.



        It's somewhat interesting that the collapse happens early in the process in a bread machine (sunken top) and a little later in hand kneading and oven baking (mushroom top with huge air bubble). Or maybe that's just my experience.



        One possibility is that your flour has absorbed moisture from the air. I now start all my bread recipes with 1/4 cup less liquid than the recipe calls for and find that I am equally likely to add flour or water to get to the right dough consistency. And after years of using a bread machine, I will say that it is far easier to judge the consistency of dough by feel (kneading) than by sight and sound (bread machine).



        Edit: I forgot to mention: bread flour (high gluten content) really does make a difference. If a recipe calls for bread flour, use that. If it calls for all purpose flour, it may or may not really need it. (Sausage buns, dinner rolls, hamburger buns are all better [softer] with all purpose flour. All the recipes in Charel Scheele's book, Old World Breads [not a bread machine cookbook, but the recipes are easy to adapt], call for all purpose flour, but I haven't found any that seem to need it and only a few [holiday breads] that seem to prefer it.) I haven't yet found a recipe that required additional gluten if you're already using bread flour, although I've found quite a few that called for it. Maybe I've just been lucky and it's the difference of environment, or maybe the people who wrote those recipes are just health nuts. (Yes, I realize a nut is someone who forcefully expresses an opinion I don't wholeheartedly agree with.)






        share|improve this answer















        This is a hard problem to diagnose. There are many things that can cause this, and trying to figure out which it is (or even if it's the same each time) can cause you to tear out your hair in frustration.



        Even so, they all basically boil down to the bread rising too fast and then collapsing. (Sure. And all my money problems are caused by expenditures exceeding income. But how do I solve that? If I just stop paying my employees, I've really cut expenditures, but I won't have any income at all!)



        One possible problem is too much liquid. The water turns to steam, puffing up the bread in the oven (or the bread machine), but then there isn't enough support structure underneath and it collapses.
        Similarly, if there's too much yeast, or it grows too fast because of too much sugar, or too little salt (part of what the salt does is inhibit yeast growth), or if you were on timer and you didn't keep the yeast out of the liquid, or the temperature was too perfect, or who knows what, the little creatures just grow too fast and give off too much carbon dioxide, which puffs up the bread, but there isn't enough support structure underneath to support it, and it collapses.



        It's somewhat interesting that the collapse happens early in the process in a bread machine (sunken top) and a little later in hand kneading and oven baking (mushroom top with huge air bubble). Or maybe that's just my experience.



        One possibility is that your flour has absorbed moisture from the air. I now start all my bread recipes with 1/4 cup less liquid than the recipe calls for and find that I am equally likely to add flour or water to get to the right dough consistency. And after years of using a bread machine, I will say that it is far easier to judge the consistency of dough by feel (kneading) than by sight and sound (bread machine).



        Edit: I forgot to mention: bread flour (high gluten content) really does make a difference. If a recipe calls for bread flour, use that. If it calls for all purpose flour, it may or may not really need it. (Sausage buns, dinner rolls, hamburger buns are all better [softer] with all purpose flour. All the recipes in Charel Scheele's book, Old World Breads [not a bread machine cookbook, but the recipes are easy to adapt], call for all purpose flour, but I haven't found any that seem to need it and only a few [holiday breads] that seem to prefer it.) I haven't yet found a recipe that required additional gluten if you're already using bread flour, although I've found quite a few that called for it. Maybe I've just been lucky and it's the difference of environment, or maybe the people who wrote those recipes are just health nuts. (Yes, I realize a nut is someone who forcefully expresses an opinion I don't wholeheartedly agree with.)







        share|improve this answer














        share|improve this answer



        share|improve this answer








        edited May 15 at 3:42

























        answered May 15 at 3:26









        sighthoundmansighthoundman

        412




        412























            1














            I have no experience with bread machines, but plenty of experience with making bread by hand, and using a mixer with a dough hook.



            Bread typically falls if you haven't baked it enough, if you haven't kneaded it enough, or if you haven't used strong flour.



            It's very difficult to diagnose the issue you're facing without more info, but here's my best educated guess... I doubt the bread is being under baked, or not kneaded enough, because you're using a machine that is designed to do it properly, so I'd bet that you're not using strong flour.



            Strong flour is suitable for this style of bread making because it contains enough gluten to provide a structure for the bread that doesn't allow air to escape. If you don't have enough gluten in your dough, or don't work the gluten enough, air will escape from your dough and your bread will fall.






            share|improve this answer


























            • I disagree with the generalizations you make here. Strong flour is not "the correct type of flour" for bread. It is the type of flour which is preferred for bread in the anglo-saxon baking tradition. It is a more recent introduction to Western Europe, while many countries farther East have great bread baking traditions without ever having produced strong flour. Ukraine, Bulgaria, Turkey, etc. bake perfect leavened breads without it. I don't know what caused this one case - but your implication that everybody should only bake with strong flour is incorrect.

              – rumtscho
              May 16 at 8:47











            • @rumtscho, apologies, I will reword my answer. I didn't intend to make that implication, I was trying to express that they could be using an unsuitable flour for this specific scenario. I was not trying to make a sweeping generalisation.

              – Doctor Jones
              May 16 at 9:11











            • Thank you for editing, it is indeed much better now.

              – rumtscho
              May 16 at 9:59
















            1














            I have no experience with bread machines, but plenty of experience with making bread by hand, and using a mixer with a dough hook.



            Bread typically falls if you haven't baked it enough, if you haven't kneaded it enough, or if you haven't used strong flour.



            It's very difficult to diagnose the issue you're facing without more info, but here's my best educated guess... I doubt the bread is being under baked, or not kneaded enough, because you're using a machine that is designed to do it properly, so I'd bet that you're not using strong flour.



            Strong flour is suitable for this style of bread making because it contains enough gluten to provide a structure for the bread that doesn't allow air to escape. If you don't have enough gluten in your dough, or don't work the gluten enough, air will escape from your dough and your bread will fall.






            share|improve this answer


























            • I disagree with the generalizations you make here. Strong flour is not "the correct type of flour" for bread. It is the type of flour which is preferred for bread in the anglo-saxon baking tradition. It is a more recent introduction to Western Europe, while many countries farther East have great bread baking traditions without ever having produced strong flour. Ukraine, Bulgaria, Turkey, etc. bake perfect leavened breads without it. I don't know what caused this one case - but your implication that everybody should only bake with strong flour is incorrect.

              – rumtscho
              May 16 at 8:47











            • @rumtscho, apologies, I will reword my answer. I didn't intend to make that implication, I was trying to express that they could be using an unsuitable flour for this specific scenario. I was not trying to make a sweeping generalisation.

              – Doctor Jones
              May 16 at 9:11











            • Thank you for editing, it is indeed much better now.

              – rumtscho
              May 16 at 9:59














            1












            1








            1







            I have no experience with bread machines, but plenty of experience with making bread by hand, and using a mixer with a dough hook.



            Bread typically falls if you haven't baked it enough, if you haven't kneaded it enough, or if you haven't used strong flour.



            It's very difficult to diagnose the issue you're facing without more info, but here's my best educated guess... I doubt the bread is being under baked, or not kneaded enough, because you're using a machine that is designed to do it properly, so I'd bet that you're not using strong flour.



            Strong flour is suitable for this style of bread making because it contains enough gluten to provide a structure for the bread that doesn't allow air to escape. If you don't have enough gluten in your dough, or don't work the gluten enough, air will escape from your dough and your bread will fall.






            share|improve this answer















            I have no experience with bread machines, but plenty of experience with making bread by hand, and using a mixer with a dough hook.



            Bread typically falls if you haven't baked it enough, if you haven't kneaded it enough, or if you haven't used strong flour.



            It's very difficult to diagnose the issue you're facing without more info, but here's my best educated guess... I doubt the bread is being under baked, or not kneaded enough, because you're using a machine that is designed to do it properly, so I'd bet that you're not using strong flour.



            Strong flour is suitable for this style of bread making because it contains enough gluten to provide a structure for the bread that doesn't allow air to escape. If you don't have enough gluten in your dough, or don't work the gluten enough, air will escape from your dough and your bread will fall.







            share|improve this answer














            share|improve this answer



            share|improve this answer








            edited May 16 at 9:04

























            answered May 15 at 10:00









            Doctor JonesDoctor Jones

            1415




            1415













            • I disagree with the generalizations you make here. Strong flour is not "the correct type of flour" for bread. It is the type of flour which is preferred for bread in the anglo-saxon baking tradition. It is a more recent introduction to Western Europe, while many countries farther East have great bread baking traditions without ever having produced strong flour. Ukraine, Bulgaria, Turkey, etc. bake perfect leavened breads without it. I don't know what caused this one case - but your implication that everybody should only bake with strong flour is incorrect.

              – rumtscho
              May 16 at 8:47











            • @rumtscho, apologies, I will reword my answer. I didn't intend to make that implication, I was trying to express that they could be using an unsuitable flour for this specific scenario. I was not trying to make a sweeping generalisation.

              – Doctor Jones
              May 16 at 9:11











            • Thank you for editing, it is indeed much better now.

              – rumtscho
              May 16 at 9:59



















            • I disagree with the generalizations you make here. Strong flour is not "the correct type of flour" for bread. It is the type of flour which is preferred for bread in the anglo-saxon baking tradition. It is a more recent introduction to Western Europe, while many countries farther East have great bread baking traditions without ever having produced strong flour. Ukraine, Bulgaria, Turkey, etc. bake perfect leavened breads without it. I don't know what caused this one case - but your implication that everybody should only bake with strong flour is incorrect.

              – rumtscho
              May 16 at 8:47











            • @rumtscho, apologies, I will reword my answer. I didn't intend to make that implication, I was trying to express that they could be using an unsuitable flour for this specific scenario. I was not trying to make a sweeping generalisation.

              – Doctor Jones
              May 16 at 9:11











            • Thank you for editing, it is indeed much better now.

              – rumtscho
              May 16 at 9:59

















            I disagree with the generalizations you make here. Strong flour is not "the correct type of flour" for bread. It is the type of flour which is preferred for bread in the anglo-saxon baking tradition. It is a more recent introduction to Western Europe, while many countries farther East have great bread baking traditions without ever having produced strong flour. Ukraine, Bulgaria, Turkey, etc. bake perfect leavened breads without it. I don't know what caused this one case - but your implication that everybody should only bake with strong flour is incorrect.

            – rumtscho
            May 16 at 8:47





            I disagree with the generalizations you make here. Strong flour is not "the correct type of flour" for bread. It is the type of flour which is preferred for bread in the anglo-saxon baking tradition. It is a more recent introduction to Western Europe, while many countries farther East have great bread baking traditions without ever having produced strong flour. Ukraine, Bulgaria, Turkey, etc. bake perfect leavened breads without it. I don't know what caused this one case - but your implication that everybody should only bake with strong flour is incorrect.

            – rumtscho
            May 16 at 8:47













            @rumtscho, apologies, I will reword my answer. I didn't intend to make that implication, I was trying to express that they could be using an unsuitable flour for this specific scenario. I was not trying to make a sweeping generalisation.

            – Doctor Jones
            May 16 at 9:11





            @rumtscho, apologies, I will reword my answer. I didn't intend to make that implication, I was trying to express that they could be using an unsuitable flour for this specific scenario. I was not trying to make a sweeping generalisation.

            – Doctor Jones
            May 16 at 9:11













            Thank you for editing, it is indeed much better now.

            – rumtscho
            May 16 at 9:59





            Thank you for editing, it is indeed much better now.

            – rumtscho
            May 16 at 9:59


















            draft saved

            draft discarded




















































            Thanks for contributing an answer to Seasoned Advice!


            • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

            But avoid



            • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

            • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


            To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




            draft saved


            draft discarded














            StackExchange.ready(
            function () {
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fcooking.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f98991%2fmy-bread-in-my-bread-maker-rises-and-then-falls-down-just-after-cooking-starts%23new-answer', 'question_page');
            }
            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown





















































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown

































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown







            Popular posts from this blog

            Færeyskur hestur Heimild | Tengill | Tilvísanir | LeiðsagnarvalRossið - síða um færeyska hrossið á færeyskuGott ár hjá færeyska hestinum

            He _____ here since 1970 . Answer needed [closed]What does “since he was so high” mean?Meaning of “catch birds for”?How do I ensure “since” takes the meaning I want?“Who cares here” meaningWhat does “right round toward” mean?the time tense (had now been detected)What does the phrase “ring around the roses” mean here?Correct usage of “visited upon”Meaning of “foiled rail sabotage bid”It was the third time I had gone to Rome or It is the third time I had been to Rome

            Slayer Innehåll Historia | Stil, komposition och lyrik | Bandets betydelse och framgångar | Sidoprojekt och samarbeten | Kontroverser | Medlemmar | Utmärkelser och nomineringar | Turnéer och festivaler | Diskografi | Referenser | Externa länkar | Navigeringsmenywww.slayer.net”Metal Massacre vol. 1””Metal Massacre vol. 3””Metal Massacre Volume III””Show No Mercy””Haunting the Chapel””Live Undead””Hell Awaits””Reign in Blood””Reign in Blood””Gold & Platinum – Reign in Blood””Golden Gods Awards Winners”originalet”Kerrang! Hall Of Fame””Slayer Looks Back On 37-Year Career In New Video Series: Part Two””South of Heaven””Gold & Platinum – South of Heaven””Seasons in the Abyss””Gold & Platinum - Seasons in the Abyss””Divine Intervention””Divine Intervention - Release group by Slayer””Gold & Platinum - Divine Intervention””Live Intrusion””Undisputed Attitude””Abolish Government/Superficial Love””Release “Slatanic Slaughter: A Tribute to Slayer” by Various Artists””Diabolus in Musica””Soundtrack to the Apocalypse””God Hates Us All””Systematic - Relationships””War at the Warfield””Gold & Platinum - War at the Warfield””Soundtrack to the Apocalypse””Gold & Platinum - Still Reigning””Metallica, Slayer, Iron Mauden Among Winners At Metal Hammer Awards””Eternal Pyre””Eternal Pyre - Slayer release group””Eternal Pyre””Metal Storm Awards 2006””Kerrang! Hall Of Fame””Slayer Wins 'Best Metal' Grammy Award””Slayer Guitarist Jeff Hanneman Dies””Bullet-For My Valentine booed at Metal Hammer Golden Gods Awards””Unholy Aliance””The End Of Slayer?””Slayer: We Could Thrash Out Two More Albums If We're Fast Enough...””'The Unholy Alliance: Chapter III' UK Dates Added”originalet”Megadeth And Slayer To Co-Headline 'Canadian Carnage' Trek”originalet”World Painted Blood””Release “World Painted Blood” by Slayer””Metallica Heading To Cinemas””Slayer, Megadeth To Join Forces For 'European Carnage' Tour - Dec. 18, 2010”originalet”Slayer's Hanneman Contracts Acute Infection; Band To Bring In Guest Guitarist””Cannibal Corpse's Pat O'Brien Will Step In As Slayer's Guest Guitarist”originalet”Slayer’s Jeff Hanneman Dead at 49””Dave Lombardo Says He Made Only $67,000 In 2011 While Touring With Slayer””Slayer: We Do Not Agree With Dave Lombardo's Substance Or Timeline Of Events””Slayer Welcomes Drummer Paul Bostaph Back To The Fold””Slayer Hope to Unveil Never-Before-Heard Jeff Hanneman Material on Next Album””Slayer Debut New Song 'Implode' During Surprise Golden Gods Appearance””Release group Repentless by Slayer””Repentless - Slayer - Credits””Slayer””Metal Storm Awards 2015””Slayer - to release comic book "Repentless #1"””Slayer To Release 'Repentless' 6.66" Vinyl Box Set””BREAKING NEWS: Slayer Announce Farewell Tour””Slayer Recruit Lamb of God, Anthrax, Behemoth + Testament for Final Tour””Slayer lägger ner efter 37 år””Slayer Announces Second North American Leg Of 'Final' Tour””Final World Tour””Slayer Announces Final European Tour With Lamb of God, Anthrax And Obituary””Slayer To Tour Europe With Lamb of God, Anthrax And Obituary””Slayer To Play 'Last French Show Ever' At Next Year's Hellfst””Slayer's Final World Tour Will Extend Into 2019””Death Angel's Rob Cavestany On Slayer's 'Farewell' Tour: 'Some Of Us Could See This Coming'””Testament Has No Plans To Retire Anytime Soon, Says Chuck Billy””Anthrax's Scott Ian On Slayer's 'Farewell' Tour Plans: 'I Was Surprised And I Wasn't Surprised'””Slayer””Slayer's Morbid Schlock””Review/Rock; For Slayer, the Mania Is the Message””Slayer - Biography””Slayer - Reign In Blood”originalet”Dave Lombardo””An exclusive oral history of Slayer”originalet”Exclusive! Interview With Slayer Guitarist Jeff Hanneman”originalet”Thinking Out Loud: Slayer's Kerry King on hair metal, Satan and being polite””Slayer Lyrics””Slayer - Biography””Most influential artists for extreme metal music””Slayer - Reign in Blood””Slayer guitarist Jeff Hanneman dies aged 49””Slatanic Slaughter: A Tribute to Slayer””Gateway to Hell: A Tribute to Slayer””Covered In Blood””Slayer: The Origins of Thrash in San Francisco, CA.””Why They Rule - #6 Slayer”originalet”Guitar World's 100 Greatest Heavy Metal Guitarists Of All Time”originalet”The fans have spoken: Slayer comes out on top in readers' polls”originalet”Tribute to Jeff Hanneman (1964-2013)””Lamb Of God Frontman: We Sound Like A Slayer Rip-Off””BEHEMOTH Frontman Pays Tribute To SLAYER's JEFF HANNEMAN””Slayer, Hatebreed Doing Double Duty On This Year's Ozzfest””System of a Down””Lacuna Coil’s Andrea Ferro Talks Influences, Skateboarding, Band Origins + More””Slayer - Reign in Blood””Into The Lungs of Hell””Slayer rules - en utställning om fans””Slayer and Their Fans Slashed Through a No-Holds-Barred Night at Gas Monkey””Home””Slayer””Gold & Platinum - The Big 4 Live from Sofia, Bulgaria””Exclusive! Interview With Slayer Guitarist Kerry King””2008-02-23: Wiltern, Los Angeles, CA, USA””Slayer's Kerry King To Perform With Megadeth Tonight! - Oct. 21, 2010”originalet”Dave Lombardo - Biography”Slayer Case DismissedArkiveradUltimate Classic Rock: Slayer guitarist Jeff Hanneman dead at 49.”Slayer: "We could never do any thing like Some Kind Of Monster..."””Cannibal Corpse'S Pat O'Brien Will Step In As Slayer'S Guest Guitarist | The Official Slayer Site”originalet”Slayer Wins 'Best Metal' Grammy Award””Slayer Guitarist Jeff Hanneman Dies””Kerrang! Awards 2006 Blog: Kerrang! Hall Of Fame””Kerrang! Awards 2013: Kerrang! Legend”originalet”Metallica, Slayer, Iron Maien Among Winners At Metal Hammer Awards””Metal Hammer Golden Gods Awards””Bullet For My Valentine Booed At Metal Hammer Golden Gods Awards””Metal Storm Awards 2006””Metal Storm Awards 2015””Slayer's Concert History””Slayer - Relationships””Slayer - Releases”Slayers officiella webbplatsSlayer på MusicBrainzOfficiell webbplatsSlayerSlayerr1373445760000 0001 1540 47353068615-5086262726cb13906545x(data)6033143kn20030215029