Why doesn't root need the password to run “sudo” even when “NOPASSWD:ALL” isn't written in...
Multi tool use
This question already has an answer here:
Why can `root` run any command as any user without providing password?
2 answers
In /etc/sudoers, there is always:
root ALL=(ALL:ALL) ALL
However, the root user (with UID 0) doesn't need to enter password when they run sudo command.
For other users, a password is required unless their entry contains NOPASSWD or a previous authentication hasn't timed out:
user ALL=(ALL:ALL) NOPASSWD:ALL
^^^^^^^^
linux sudo root
asked yesterday
iBugiBug
1,0181031
marked as duplicate by muru, roaima, msp9011, nwildner, Anthony Geoghegan 20 hours ago
This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.
add a comment |
This question already has an answer here:
Why can `root` run any command as any user without providing password?
2 answers
In /etc/sudoers, there is always:
root ALL=(ALL:ALL) ALL
However, the root user (with UID 0) doesn't need to enter password when they run sudo command.
For other users, a password is required unless their entry contains NOPASSWD or a previous authentication hasn't timed out:
user ALL=(ALL:ALL) NOPASSWD:ALL
^^^^^^^^
linux sudo root
asked yesterday
iBugiBug
1,0181031
marked as duplicate by muru, roaima, msp9011, nwildner, Anthony Geoghegan 20 hours ago
This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.
This is a bit weird actually. Even though you'd usually usesudoto run commands as UID 0, and root is already UID 0 and there's nothing to gain by stopping them,sudostill requires the config line forrootto be there. Without it, it tells even root to bugger off.
– ilkkachu
yesterday
Cause it isroot. What would you gain runningsudoas root? "Beyond Root"? "Who watch the Watchmen?"
– nwildner
21 hours ago
add a comment |
This question already has an answer here:
Why can `root` run any command as any user without providing password?
2 answers
In /etc/sudoers, there is always:
root ALL=(ALL:ALL) ALL
However, the root user (with UID 0) doesn't need to enter password when they run sudo command.
For other users, a password is required unless their entry contains NOPASSWD or a previous authentication hasn't timed out:
user ALL=(ALL:ALL) NOPASSWD:ALL
^^^^^^^^
linux sudo root
asked yesterday
iBugiBug
1,0181031
This question already has an answer here:
Why can `root` run any command as any user without providing password?
2 answers
In /etc/sudoers, there is always:
root ALL=(ALL:ALL) ALL
However, the root user (with UID 0) doesn't need to enter password when they run sudo command.
For other users, a password is required unless their entry contains NOPASSWD or a previous authentication hasn't timed out:
user ALL=(ALL:ALL) NOPASSWD:ALL
^^^^^^^^
This question already has an answer here:
Why can `root` run any command as any user without providing password?
2 answers
linux sudo root
linux sudo root
asked yesterday
iBugiBug
1,0181031
asked yesterday
iBugiBug
1,0181031
edited yesterday
iBug
asked yesterday
iBugiBug
1,0181031
asked yesterday
iBugiBug
1,0181031
asked yesterday
iBugiBug
1,0181031
1,0181031
marked as duplicate by muru, roaima, msp9011, nwildner, Anthony Geoghegan 20 hours ago
This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.
marked as duplicate by muru, roaima, msp9011, nwildner, Anthony Geoghegan 20 hours ago
This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.
This is a bit weird actually. Even though you'd usually usesudoto run commands as UID 0, and root is already UID 0 and there's nothing to gain by stopping them,sudostill requires the config line forrootto be there. Without it, it tells even root to bugger off.
– ilkkachu
yesterday
Cause it isroot. What would you gain runningsudoas root? "Beyond Root"? "Who watch the Watchmen?"
– nwildner
21 hours ago
add a comment |
This is a bit weird actually. Even though you'd usually usesudoto run commands as UID 0, and root is already UID 0 and there's nothing to gain by stopping them,sudostill requires the config line forrootto be there. Without it, it tells even root to bugger off.
– ilkkachu
yesterday
Cause it isroot. What would you gain runningsudoas root? "Beyond Root"? "Who watch the Watchmen?"
– nwildner
21 hours ago
This is a bit weird actually. Even though you'd usually use
sudo to run commands as UID 0, and root is already UID 0 and there's nothing to gain by stopping them, sudo still requires the config line for root to be there. Without it, it tells even root to bugger off.– ilkkachu
yesterday
This is a bit weird actually. Even though you'd usually use
sudo to run commands as UID 0, and root is already UID 0 and there's nothing to gain by stopping them, sudo still requires the config line for root to be there. Without it, it tells even root to bugger off.– ilkkachu
yesterday
Cause it is
root. What would you gain running sudo as root? "Beyond Root"? "Who watch the Watchmen?"– nwildner
21 hours ago
Cause it is
root. What would you gain running sudo as root? "Beyond Root"? "Who watch the Watchmen?"– nwildner
21 hours ago
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
sudo allows users to execute commands as UID 0 (or other users) based on how it’s configured. There is no need to ask root for a password to run a command as UID 0, because it already is UID 0.
Furthermore, root can also su to anyone it’d like, so there’s no need to prompt for a password when executing sudo -u user as UID 0.
Note: I do believe there is a PAM setting that will even require root to provide a password for the target user when using su.
answered yesterday
PeschkePeschke
2,841926
add a comment |
While this is an interesting inconsistency. It would be pointless in stopping root, as root has capabilities CAP_SETUID and CAP_SETGID, so does not need sudo. It can do what ever it want.
If sudo is checking root, and not these capabilities, then there may be a latent-bug: root with no capabilities could escalate (I don't know I have not looked at the code, or tested).
answered yesterday
ctrl-alt-delorctrl-alt-delor
12.1k42561
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
sudo allows users to execute commands as UID 0 (or other users) based on how it’s configured. There is no need to ask root for a password to run a command as UID 0, because it already is UID 0.
Furthermore, root can also su to anyone it’d like, so there’s no need to prompt for a password when executing sudo -u user as UID 0.
Note: I do believe there is a PAM setting that will even require root to provide a password for the target user when using su.
answered yesterday
PeschkePeschke
2,841926
add a comment |
sudo allows users to execute commands as UID 0 (or other users) based on how it’s configured. There is no need to ask root for a password to run a command as UID 0, because it already is UID 0.
Furthermore, root can also su to anyone it’d like, so there’s no need to prompt for a password when executing sudo -u user as UID 0.
Note: I do believe there is a PAM setting that will even require root to provide a password for the target user when using su.
answered yesterday
PeschkePeschke
2,841926
add a comment |
sudo allows users to execute commands as UID 0 (or other users) based on how it’s configured. There is no need to ask root for a password to run a command as UID 0, because it already is UID 0.
Furthermore, root can also su to anyone it’d like, so there’s no need to prompt for a password when executing sudo -u user as UID 0.
Note: I do believe there is a PAM setting that will even require root to provide a password for the target user when using su.
answered yesterday
PeschkePeschke
2,841926
sudo allows users to execute commands as UID 0 (or other users) based on how it’s configured. There is no need to ask root for a password to run a command as UID 0, because it already is UID 0.
Furthermore, root can also su to anyone it’d like, so there’s no need to prompt for a password when executing sudo -u user as UID 0.
Note: I do believe there is a PAM setting that will even require root to provide a password for the target user when using su.
answered yesterday
PeschkePeschke
2,841926
answered yesterday
PeschkePeschke
2,841926
answered yesterday
PeschkePeschke
2,841926
answered yesterday
PeschkePeschke
2,841926
2,841926
add a comment |
add a comment |
While this is an interesting inconsistency. It would be pointless in stopping root, as root has capabilities CAP_SETUID and CAP_SETGID, so does not need sudo. It can do what ever it want.
If sudo is checking root, and not these capabilities, then there may be a latent-bug: root with no capabilities could escalate (I don't know I have not looked at the code, or tested).
answered yesterday
ctrl-alt-delorctrl-alt-delor
12.1k42561
add a comment |
While this is an interesting inconsistency. It would be pointless in stopping root, as root has capabilities CAP_SETUID and CAP_SETGID, so does not need sudo. It can do what ever it want.
If sudo is checking root, and not these capabilities, then there may be a latent-bug: root with no capabilities could escalate (I don't know I have not looked at the code, or tested).
answered yesterday
ctrl-alt-delorctrl-alt-delor
12.1k42561
add a comment |
While this is an interesting inconsistency. It would be pointless in stopping root, as root has capabilities CAP_SETUID and CAP_SETGID, so does not need sudo. It can do what ever it want.
If sudo is checking root, and not these capabilities, then there may be a latent-bug: root with no capabilities could escalate (I don't know I have not looked at the code, or tested).
answered yesterday
ctrl-alt-delorctrl-alt-delor
12.1k42561
While this is an interesting inconsistency. It would be pointless in stopping root, as root has capabilities CAP_SETUID and CAP_SETGID, so does not need sudo. It can do what ever it want.
If sudo is checking root, and not these capabilities, then there may be a latent-bug: root with no capabilities could escalate (I don't know I have not looked at the code, or tested).
answered yesterday
ctrl-alt-delorctrl-alt-delor
12.1k42561
answered yesterday
ctrl-alt-delorctrl-alt-delor
12.1k42561
answered yesterday
ctrl-alt-delorctrl-alt-delor
12.1k42561
answered yesterday
ctrl-alt-delorctrl-alt-delor
12.1k42561
12.1k42561
add a comment |
add a comment |
lMZ38fHonn,VLiB2zk1qtVjfhcwAJ8K RsMR 5NH0,OikbXRp50Yl keMITAx AlhZsELfVi7wQ,xBZ
This is a bit weird actually. Even though you'd usually use
sudoto run commands as UID 0, and root is already UID 0 and there's nothing to gain by stopping them,sudostill requires the config line forrootto be there. Without it, it tells even root to bugger off.– ilkkachu
yesterday
Cause it is
root. What would you gain runningsudoas root? "Beyond Root"? "Who watch the Watchmen?"– nwildner
21 hours ago