Stereotypical names Unicorn Meta Zoo #1: Why another podcast? Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara Announcing our contest results! Tags of the week! April 22-28, 2019: Essay & MarketingTools for generating characters' namesWhat connotations do these character names confer?Writing a character that has many namesAre words like 'cunt' too provocative for use in the current fiction market?Guidance on pacing the introduction of new charactersWhen naming a character, is thematic naming or realistic naming more important?Are connotations with certain names inevitable?organising complex networksGiving nonsensical names to thingsHow to describe my character using they/them so the reader doesn't know their gender until their pronouns show up later?

What helicopter has the most rotor blades?

Philosophers who were composers?

When speaking, how do you change your mind mid-sentence?

My admission is revoked after accepting the admission offer

What does the black goddess statue do and what is it?

Writing a T-SQL stored procedure to receive 4 numbers and insert them into a table

Why isPrototypeOf() returns false?

In search of the origins of term censor, I hit a dead end stuck with the greek term, to censor, λογοκρίνω

How to keep bees out of canned beverages?

Getting AggregateResult variables from Execute Anonymous Window

What's called a person who works as someone who puts products on shelves in stores?

Array Dynamic resize in heap

Where did Arya get these scars?

Co-worker works way more than he should

Errors in solving coupled pdes

How can I wire a 9-position switch so that each position turns on one more LED than the one before?

Are these square matrices always diagonalisable?

/bin/ls sorts differently than just ls

Was there ever a LEGO store in Miami International Airport?

Why did Europeans not widely domesticate foxes?

Stretch a Tikz tree

What is the numbering system used for the DSN dishes?

Did war bonds have better investment alternatives during WWII?

Protagonist's race is hidden - should I reveal it?



Stereotypical names



Unicorn Meta Zoo #1: Why another podcast?
Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara
Announcing our contest results!
Tags of the week! April 22-28, 2019: Essay & MarketingTools for generating characters' namesWhat connotations do these character names confer?Writing a character that has many namesAre words like 'cunt' too provocative for use in the current fiction market?Guidance on pacing the introduction of new charactersWhen naming a character, is thematic naming or realistic naming more important?Are connotations with certain names inevitable?organising complex networksGiving nonsensical names to thingsHow to describe my character using they/them so the reader doesn't know their gender until their pronouns show up later?










10















In every country, some names are particularly common: 'John' in the UK, 'Juan' in Spain, 'Ivan' in Russia. Those names are common almost to the point of being stereotypical (consider 'John Doe').



If I have no more than one or two characters from a particular place, is it bad form to use those extremely common names? On the one hand, those names are common, that's real life. It is quite realistic to have a character from that location carry that name. On the other hand, it feels almost lazy to have a guy from Spain named Juan, and his sister is of course Maria. Like I couldn't be bothered to do the research and find some other names, and went with the most stereotypical ones instead.



Is there a way to strike a balance between conveying a strong sense of location with the names, and not being "too stereotypical"? (My particular situation is a setting in space with people from all over.)










share|improve this question



















  • 2





    Personal anecdote - most people I've known with a very common name tended to go by a nickname. Usually some derivative of their actual name but other times it could be anything. And it's quite rare to know two people with very common names under the same nickname, even if based on their actual name. Thing is, it's so common that they, and the people around them, have to differentiate.

    – VLAZ
    Mar 26 at 13:38















10















In every country, some names are particularly common: 'John' in the UK, 'Juan' in Spain, 'Ivan' in Russia. Those names are common almost to the point of being stereotypical (consider 'John Doe').



If I have no more than one or two characters from a particular place, is it bad form to use those extremely common names? On the one hand, those names are common, that's real life. It is quite realistic to have a character from that location carry that name. On the other hand, it feels almost lazy to have a guy from Spain named Juan, and his sister is of course Maria. Like I couldn't be bothered to do the research and find some other names, and went with the most stereotypical ones instead.



Is there a way to strike a balance between conveying a strong sense of location with the names, and not being "too stereotypical"? (My particular situation is a setting in space with people from all over.)










share|improve this question



















  • 2





    Personal anecdote - most people I've known with a very common name tended to go by a nickname. Usually some derivative of their actual name but other times it could be anything. And it's quite rare to know two people with very common names under the same nickname, even if based on their actual name. Thing is, it's so common that they, and the people around them, have to differentiate.

    – VLAZ
    Mar 26 at 13:38













10












10








10


2






In every country, some names are particularly common: 'John' in the UK, 'Juan' in Spain, 'Ivan' in Russia. Those names are common almost to the point of being stereotypical (consider 'John Doe').



If I have no more than one or two characters from a particular place, is it bad form to use those extremely common names? On the one hand, those names are common, that's real life. It is quite realistic to have a character from that location carry that name. On the other hand, it feels almost lazy to have a guy from Spain named Juan, and his sister is of course Maria. Like I couldn't be bothered to do the research and find some other names, and went with the most stereotypical ones instead.



Is there a way to strike a balance between conveying a strong sense of location with the names, and not being "too stereotypical"? (My particular situation is a setting in space with people from all over.)










share|improve this question
















In every country, some names are particularly common: 'John' in the UK, 'Juan' in Spain, 'Ivan' in Russia. Those names are common almost to the point of being stereotypical (consider 'John Doe').



If I have no more than one or two characters from a particular place, is it bad form to use those extremely common names? On the one hand, those names are common, that's real life. It is quite realistic to have a character from that location carry that name. On the other hand, it feels almost lazy to have a guy from Spain named Juan, and his sister is of course Maria. Like I couldn't be bothered to do the research and find some other names, and went with the most stereotypical ones instead.



Is there a way to strike a balance between conveying a strong sense of location with the names, and not being "too stereotypical"? (My particular situation is a setting in space with people from all over.)







creative-writing characters naming






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited Mar 25 at 20:56









Alexander

3,700413




3,700413










asked Mar 25 at 20:30









GalastelGalastel

38.2k6114205




38.2k6114205







  • 2





    Personal anecdote - most people I've known with a very common name tended to go by a nickname. Usually some derivative of their actual name but other times it could be anything. And it's quite rare to know two people with very common names under the same nickname, even if based on their actual name. Thing is, it's so common that they, and the people around them, have to differentiate.

    – VLAZ
    Mar 26 at 13:38












  • 2





    Personal anecdote - most people I've known with a very common name tended to go by a nickname. Usually some derivative of their actual name but other times it could be anything. And it's quite rare to know two people with very common names under the same nickname, even if based on their actual name. Thing is, it's so common that they, and the people around them, have to differentiate.

    – VLAZ
    Mar 26 at 13:38







2




2





Personal anecdote - most people I've known with a very common name tended to go by a nickname. Usually some derivative of their actual name but other times it could be anything. And it's quite rare to know two people with very common names under the same nickname, even if based on their actual name. Thing is, it's so common that they, and the people around them, have to differentiate.

– VLAZ
Mar 26 at 13:38





Personal anecdote - most people I've known with a very common name tended to go by a nickname. Usually some derivative of their actual name but other times it could be anything. And it's quite rare to know two people with very common names under the same nickname, even if based on their actual name. Thing is, it's so common that they, and the people around them, have to differentiate.

– VLAZ
Mar 26 at 13:38










9 Answers
9






active

oldest

votes


















8














I want to add that some "stereotypical" names are actually not as common as one would think. This is something that readers familiar with the country in question will notice, and is sometimes the main problem with stereotypical names.



For example the Russian name Ivan: I've never actually met a Russian named Ivan. I have met Russians called Alexej, Sergey, Wladimir, Sasha, and Andrei, however. None of the Russian authors I read and love have this name (Fjodor, Arkadi, Boris, Leo, ...). I don't know for sure, I think the name might be an outdated stereotype, i.e. the name might have been common once but not anymore, or it might be a name that is more common in a specific social class, the working class for example.



It's the same with some German names like Michel, Fritz, Franz, Otto, Hans, Heinz etc. that were common up until the early 20th century, but now are much less popular. (Though some German names have had a comeback, for example Anton.) Here it might be related to the Third Reich and how typically German names left a bad taste with some people in the aftermath, but I don't know for sure. In any case Germans in foreign literature still often have one of these names, even if the novel is set in modern times, and it's always jarring. Biblical names like Tobias, David, Simon, Jonas etc. are now much more common.



So I would say that using stereotypical names is not necessarily bad form, but you have to know where the stereotype comes from, and if it is relevant to the time period your novel is set in.






share|improve this answer






























    7














    I look for popular names, but not the MOST popular names. For example, I just googled "most popular names in the UK" and found this at the top link. An excerpt:



    Boys



    Oliver - 6,259
    Harry - 5,031
    George - 4,929
    Noah - 4,273
    Jack - 4,190
    Jacob - 3,968
    Leo - 3,781
    Oscar - 3,739
    Charlie - 3,724
    Muhammad - 3,691


    Girls



    Olivia - 5,204
    Amelia - 4,358
    Isla - 3,373
    Ava - 3,289
    Emily - 3,121
    Isabella - 2,627
    Mia - 2,590
    Poppy - 2,527
    Ella - 2,452
    Lily - 2,405


    Just pick something not in the top 5, it would be realistic, but not obviously stereotypical of the region.






    share|improve this answer


















    • 9





      Anyone else amused by the #1 names in both lists being the male and female equivalents of each other?

      – Mason Wheeler
      Mar 25 at 21:54






    • 9





      For extra credit: Consider the age of your character and use the "most popular" list of the correct year (or, at least, the correct "generation").

      – Heinzi
      Mar 26 at 10:46







    • 3





      @DoctorPenguin - Well, that list is for the entire UK, which of course includes Scotland. I suspect if you looked for one of just England you'd have different results. You could probably localize it even more, as I suspect that you won't see the same list from e.g. London vs. Liverpool, etc.

      – Darrel Hoffman
      Mar 26 at 13:58






    • 2





      My guess would be that although the Scottish population is smaller, the choice of names among that population is much less diverse, so some names bubble up just because they have less to choose from. This would be the same reason why Muhammed is so high up on the list - it's not just that there's a large percentage of Muslims living in the UK, it's that the diversity of names among Muslims is just generally much smaller than among other cultures. (I believe that Muhammed is the #1 most common name worldwide for that same reason.)

      – Darrel Hoffman
      Mar 26 at 14:24






    • 1





      @MasonWheeler, I was amused that OPs list of common names for each country were all the same name!

      – Glen Yates
      Mar 26 at 18:10


















    5














    The problem about this is that most of the time we want to read something about special people. Sure, we want to be able to sympathize with the character and for example superhero comics have a history of making it look like everyone could be Superman - or Shazam the 14-year-old-boy-transformed-into-a-superhero - but characters in books, comics, etc. tend to be special in some regards. By giving your protagonist a name that seemingly every second person has they can appear quite boring.



    What name do you think would be more memorable: "Shazam" or "Billy"?



    Yes, the protagonist in the linked comic series is named "Billy", quite the typical name. But most people will likely find his superhero form more memorable. Maybe you could use this and give your "Juan" and "Maria" interesting and memorable nicknames. Especially if they have a name that seemingly everyone else around them had that could be a reason to try and stand out. How do your characters feel about their name? Do they like this typical name? Maybe they like the feeling of proudly representing the majority. Or maybe they want to be special. Different. Not just another "Juan" or "Maria".



    A lot of this depends on the setting. In fantasy or sci-fi settings it's far easier to just come up with new names. In modern day settings like in a thriller you will more likely use "normal" names. But this also depends on a lot of factors. Are you in a rural area where older names are more present? Or a metropolitan city with influences from all around the globe? Is the social class of your characters focused on traditions or innovation?



    As you mention that you have a setting with lots of people from all over the world you could use steretypical names a few times. Maybe one or two out of a group of five people would feel like something that can actually happen while still not feeling as if you were simply too lazy to look up other names. But you should think about other options to refer to these characters and you should think about how the characters feel about their own names.






    share|improve this answer























    • Of course at this point with genre expectations, "Billy the superhero" would actually be unusual and memorable, like "Bob the stone troll" or "Tim the enchanter". Would also indicate a comic lean, though.

      – StarWeaver
      Mar 26 at 16:37


















    5














    It is bad when your "national" character is one-dimensional. It is perfectly fine when this character is non-stereotypical.



    Creating a "representative" characters with stereotypical names is a bad (and well-worn) practice when those characters also reinforce popular stereotypes of a certain nation or racial group. On the other hand, if such character has depth and well-developed, steretotypical name becomes insignificant.



    This trope was humorously subverted in the 2002 movie The Cuckoo, in which one of the main characters, a Russian, has name "Ivan", but his newfound friend, Finnish sniper Veikko is not believing it because




    when they first met and Veikko asks for Ivan's name, Ivan replies "Get lost!" (in Russian) - and this is how Veikko had called him ever since.







    share|improve this answer
































      5














      It depends on what sort of story you want to write.



      If you want your character to stand out (superhero, famous outlaw, rebel leader, etc.) it's probably better to pick a name that stands out.



      If you're trying to show that this is an ordinary person, living an ordinary life, then using something more common can be an effective tool. Think of Winston Smith from 1984 - his last name's meant to sound like a generic, boring British guy. There's nothing particularly remarkable about him. He's a guy who tries to rebel and fails.



      A generic name can also be an alias meant to make an interesting character sound less remarkable (spy, secret agent, etc.). For example, John Reese in the TV show Person of Interest.



      There's the humor angle, too. Maybe you're writing about some poor guy named "John Doe" that no one can take seriously.






      share|improve this answer






























        3














        There is nothing wrong with using common names for characters unless you over use them. If everyone has the most common names for their region, the readers may start paying attention to that instead of your story.



        That being said, there are ways of playing with it. You could use it to break expectations. Maybe Ivan is from the UK?



        Heck, any of them could be from the US.



        Maybe have two characters named John. One will end up being called by a nickname. My name isn't incredibly common but for one event we had five people with my first name on a radio net. That was a fun mess. With 95 people on the radio net, last names were out as well.



        Maybe have John meet Juan. Having the "same" name might be a running gag for the two.






        share|improve this answer






























          3














          Just to point out, that the names John, Juan, and Ivan (along with the Irish Sean/Shane, Scottish Ian, the French Jean, the Italian Giovanni, the German Hans and many others) are derivations of the Hebrew name Yohanna which means Yahweh (God) is Gracious. Many of the most common Middle-East and European names are derived from Biblical names. John is so common that I'm not sure if you realized that the names you selected are all John-equivalents.



          Non-Sterotypical Names tend to be Americans in fiction from outside the United States (If you've watched any BBC shows, like Doctor Who or Top Gear, when an American appears, expect someone to guess their American from the name alone, because it's a weird one). America, being a melting pot culture, could have a odd cultural mashup of names that could be because they are a mixed nationality family following a traditional naming convention (Irish families tend to name first born son in a convention that the first name is the child's paternal Grandfather, second name is child's maternal Grandfather, family name... if an Irish man marries a Hispanic woman, than the name could be Sean Roberto O'Reilly... and that's not assuming that they can always give the kid a Russian name for no reason beyond wanting to be different).



          European names to Americans tend to be stereotypical because, well, an English family is going to name their kids English Names, and the French Families are going to give their kids French Names, and the German kids will be given German Names. And each society tends to have rules about naming their kids too.






          share|improve this answer






























            3














            If you look at any group of people, some will have very common names, others well known but less common names, and a few will have unusual names. If your own characters also have a mix, you're fine. You don't want all unusual names or your reader will have trouble remember them. If they're all top names, that isn't realistic (the top names aren't the majority of names).



            Most of my modern-day characters have well-known names because the rest of my characters are from ancient times, in other parts of the world, and their names are unusual. So I needed a balance.



            If you're careful that the common names you choose are actually popular in the real life setting you're taking them from and not stereotypes elsewhere, you're reasonably okay. This is hard to suss out but one example could be Juan in the United States, even though it's a real name here and in countries that are majority Spanish-speaking. (Note: If you're American and old enough to remember certain coffee commercials (though that's not the only source of the the stereotype), you probably see my point.) Just like you'd want to avoid making the only Jewish characters in a story Abraham and Sarah (unless of course it's a Bible retelling).



            I would also avoid making all the names from a region super common ones, even if they're not stereotypes. Why make readers from those countries or with that ancestry wonder why the other characters are so much more interesting?






            share|improve this answer






























              3














              Choose names that have that countries "feel" with out being stereotypical (e.g. Alejandro -Mexico, or Aleksandr -Russia)



              As I interpret it, your main aim is to have the character's country of origin obvious from their name ("strong sense of location with the names"). Stereotypical names will obviously do that, but as others have pointed out, these names may not even be popular in this day and age and having too many stereotypical names may make the story and characters seem less... complex?



              So why not look up names online and pick ones that are not stereotypical names but still have that countries "feel" to them. For example when I look up Mexican girls names I see that Maria is number one (and very stereotypical) but plenty of the others "feel" Mexican without me ever having heard the name before (or rarely): Juana, Margarita, Verónica, Alejandra, María Elena...



              You could also just pick a common name (e.g. Alexander) and look up that name in Spanish or Russian (Alejandro -Spanish, Aleksandr -Russia). Again I've never met an Alejandro or an Aleksandr but I could give you a good guess as to what part of the world their name is from.






              share|improve this answer























                Your Answer








                StackExchange.ready(function()
                var channelOptions =
                tags: "".split(" "),
                id: "166"
                ;
                initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

                StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
                // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
                if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
                StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
                createEditor();
                );

                else
                createEditor();

                );

                function createEditor()
                StackExchange.prepareEditor(
                heartbeatType: 'answer',
                autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
                convertImagesToLinks: false,
                noModals: true,
                showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
                reputationToPostImages: null,
                bindNavPrevention: true,
                postfix: "",
                imageUploader:
                brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
                contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
                allowUrls: true
                ,
                noCode: true, onDemand: true,
                discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
                ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
                );



                );













                draft saved

                draft discarded


















                StackExchange.ready(
                function ()
                StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fwriting.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f44023%2fstereotypical-names%23new-answer', 'question_page');

                );

                Post as a guest















                Required, but never shown

























                9 Answers
                9






                active

                oldest

                votes








                9 Answers
                9






                active

                oldest

                votes









                active

                oldest

                votes






                active

                oldest

                votes









                8














                I want to add that some "stereotypical" names are actually not as common as one would think. This is something that readers familiar with the country in question will notice, and is sometimes the main problem with stereotypical names.



                For example the Russian name Ivan: I've never actually met a Russian named Ivan. I have met Russians called Alexej, Sergey, Wladimir, Sasha, and Andrei, however. None of the Russian authors I read and love have this name (Fjodor, Arkadi, Boris, Leo, ...). I don't know for sure, I think the name might be an outdated stereotype, i.e. the name might have been common once but not anymore, or it might be a name that is more common in a specific social class, the working class for example.



                It's the same with some German names like Michel, Fritz, Franz, Otto, Hans, Heinz etc. that were common up until the early 20th century, but now are much less popular. (Though some German names have had a comeback, for example Anton.) Here it might be related to the Third Reich and how typically German names left a bad taste with some people in the aftermath, but I don't know for sure. In any case Germans in foreign literature still often have one of these names, even if the novel is set in modern times, and it's always jarring. Biblical names like Tobias, David, Simon, Jonas etc. are now much more common.



                So I would say that using stereotypical names is not necessarily bad form, but you have to know where the stereotype comes from, and if it is relevant to the time period your novel is set in.






                share|improve this answer



























                  8














                  I want to add that some "stereotypical" names are actually not as common as one would think. This is something that readers familiar with the country in question will notice, and is sometimes the main problem with stereotypical names.



                  For example the Russian name Ivan: I've never actually met a Russian named Ivan. I have met Russians called Alexej, Sergey, Wladimir, Sasha, and Andrei, however. None of the Russian authors I read and love have this name (Fjodor, Arkadi, Boris, Leo, ...). I don't know for sure, I think the name might be an outdated stereotype, i.e. the name might have been common once but not anymore, or it might be a name that is more common in a specific social class, the working class for example.



                  It's the same with some German names like Michel, Fritz, Franz, Otto, Hans, Heinz etc. that were common up until the early 20th century, but now are much less popular. (Though some German names have had a comeback, for example Anton.) Here it might be related to the Third Reich and how typically German names left a bad taste with some people in the aftermath, but I don't know for sure. In any case Germans in foreign literature still often have one of these names, even if the novel is set in modern times, and it's always jarring. Biblical names like Tobias, David, Simon, Jonas etc. are now much more common.



                  So I would say that using stereotypical names is not necessarily bad form, but you have to know where the stereotype comes from, and if it is relevant to the time period your novel is set in.






                  share|improve this answer

























                    8












                    8








                    8







                    I want to add that some "stereotypical" names are actually not as common as one would think. This is something that readers familiar with the country in question will notice, and is sometimes the main problem with stereotypical names.



                    For example the Russian name Ivan: I've never actually met a Russian named Ivan. I have met Russians called Alexej, Sergey, Wladimir, Sasha, and Andrei, however. None of the Russian authors I read and love have this name (Fjodor, Arkadi, Boris, Leo, ...). I don't know for sure, I think the name might be an outdated stereotype, i.e. the name might have been common once but not anymore, or it might be a name that is more common in a specific social class, the working class for example.



                    It's the same with some German names like Michel, Fritz, Franz, Otto, Hans, Heinz etc. that were common up until the early 20th century, but now are much less popular. (Though some German names have had a comeback, for example Anton.) Here it might be related to the Third Reich and how typically German names left a bad taste with some people in the aftermath, but I don't know for sure. In any case Germans in foreign literature still often have one of these names, even if the novel is set in modern times, and it's always jarring. Biblical names like Tobias, David, Simon, Jonas etc. are now much more common.



                    So I would say that using stereotypical names is not necessarily bad form, but you have to know where the stereotype comes from, and if it is relevant to the time period your novel is set in.






                    share|improve this answer













                    I want to add that some "stereotypical" names are actually not as common as one would think. This is something that readers familiar with the country in question will notice, and is sometimes the main problem with stereotypical names.



                    For example the Russian name Ivan: I've never actually met a Russian named Ivan. I have met Russians called Alexej, Sergey, Wladimir, Sasha, and Andrei, however. None of the Russian authors I read and love have this name (Fjodor, Arkadi, Boris, Leo, ...). I don't know for sure, I think the name might be an outdated stereotype, i.e. the name might have been common once but not anymore, or it might be a name that is more common in a specific social class, the working class for example.



                    It's the same with some German names like Michel, Fritz, Franz, Otto, Hans, Heinz etc. that were common up until the early 20th century, but now are much less popular. (Though some German names have had a comeback, for example Anton.) Here it might be related to the Third Reich and how typically German names left a bad taste with some people in the aftermath, but I don't know for sure. In any case Germans in foreign literature still often have one of these names, even if the novel is set in modern times, and it's always jarring. Biblical names like Tobias, David, Simon, Jonas etc. are now much more common.



                    So I would say that using stereotypical names is not necessarily bad form, but you have to know where the stereotype comes from, and if it is relevant to the time period your novel is set in.







                    share|improve this answer












                    share|improve this answer



                    share|improve this answer










                    answered Mar 26 at 11:05









                    SpectrosaurusSpectrosaurus

                    1,239320




                    1,239320





















                        7














                        I look for popular names, but not the MOST popular names. For example, I just googled "most popular names in the UK" and found this at the top link. An excerpt:



                        Boys



                        Oliver - 6,259
                        Harry - 5,031
                        George - 4,929
                        Noah - 4,273
                        Jack - 4,190
                        Jacob - 3,968
                        Leo - 3,781
                        Oscar - 3,739
                        Charlie - 3,724
                        Muhammad - 3,691


                        Girls



                        Olivia - 5,204
                        Amelia - 4,358
                        Isla - 3,373
                        Ava - 3,289
                        Emily - 3,121
                        Isabella - 2,627
                        Mia - 2,590
                        Poppy - 2,527
                        Ella - 2,452
                        Lily - 2,405


                        Just pick something not in the top 5, it would be realistic, but not obviously stereotypical of the region.






                        share|improve this answer


















                        • 9





                          Anyone else amused by the #1 names in both lists being the male and female equivalents of each other?

                          – Mason Wheeler
                          Mar 25 at 21:54






                        • 9





                          For extra credit: Consider the age of your character and use the "most popular" list of the correct year (or, at least, the correct "generation").

                          – Heinzi
                          Mar 26 at 10:46







                        • 3





                          @DoctorPenguin - Well, that list is for the entire UK, which of course includes Scotland. I suspect if you looked for one of just England you'd have different results. You could probably localize it even more, as I suspect that you won't see the same list from e.g. London vs. Liverpool, etc.

                          – Darrel Hoffman
                          Mar 26 at 13:58






                        • 2





                          My guess would be that although the Scottish population is smaller, the choice of names among that population is much less diverse, so some names bubble up just because they have less to choose from. This would be the same reason why Muhammed is so high up on the list - it's not just that there's a large percentage of Muslims living in the UK, it's that the diversity of names among Muslims is just generally much smaller than among other cultures. (I believe that Muhammed is the #1 most common name worldwide for that same reason.)

                          – Darrel Hoffman
                          Mar 26 at 14:24






                        • 1





                          @MasonWheeler, I was amused that OPs list of common names for each country were all the same name!

                          – Glen Yates
                          Mar 26 at 18:10















                        7














                        I look for popular names, but not the MOST popular names. For example, I just googled "most popular names in the UK" and found this at the top link. An excerpt:



                        Boys



                        Oliver - 6,259
                        Harry - 5,031
                        George - 4,929
                        Noah - 4,273
                        Jack - 4,190
                        Jacob - 3,968
                        Leo - 3,781
                        Oscar - 3,739
                        Charlie - 3,724
                        Muhammad - 3,691


                        Girls



                        Olivia - 5,204
                        Amelia - 4,358
                        Isla - 3,373
                        Ava - 3,289
                        Emily - 3,121
                        Isabella - 2,627
                        Mia - 2,590
                        Poppy - 2,527
                        Ella - 2,452
                        Lily - 2,405


                        Just pick something not in the top 5, it would be realistic, but not obviously stereotypical of the region.






                        share|improve this answer


















                        • 9





                          Anyone else amused by the #1 names in both lists being the male and female equivalents of each other?

                          – Mason Wheeler
                          Mar 25 at 21:54






                        • 9





                          For extra credit: Consider the age of your character and use the "most popular" list of the correct year (or, at least, the correct "generation").

                          – Heinzi
                          Mar 26 at 10:46







                        • 3





                          @DoctorPenguin - Well, that list is for the entire UK, which of course includes Scotland. I suspect if you looked for one of just England you'd have different results. You could probably localize it even more, as I suspect that you won't see the same list from e.g. London vs. Liverpool, etc.

                          – Darrel Hoffman
                          Mar 26 at 13:58






                        • 2





                          My guess would be that although the Scottish population is smaller, the choice of names among that population is much less diverse, so some names bubble up just because they have less to choose from. This would be the same reason why Muhammed is so high up on the list - it's not just that there's a large percentage of Muslims living in the UK, it's that the diversity of names among Muslims is just generally much smaller than among other cultures. (I believe that Muhammed is the #1 most common name worldwide for that same reason.)

                          – Darrel Hoffman
                          Mar 26 at 14:24






                        • 1





                          @MasonWheeler, I was amused that OPs list of common names for each country were all the same name!

                          – Glen Yates
                          Mar 26 at 18:10













                        7












                        7








                        7







                        I look for popular names, but not the MOST popular names. For example, I just googled "most popular names in the UK" and found this at the top link. An excerpt:



                        Boys



                        Oliver - 6,259
                        Harry - 5,031
                        George - 4,929
                        Noah - 4,273
                        Jack - 4,190
                        Jacob - 3,968
                        Leo - 3,781
                        Oscar - 3,739
                        Charlie - 3,724
                        Muhammad - 3,691


                        Girls



                        Olivia - 5,204
                        Amelia - 4,358
                        Isla - 3,373
                        Ava - 3,289
                        Emily - 3,121
                        Isabella - 2,627
                        Mia - 2,590
                        Poppy - 2,527
                        Ella - 2,452
                        Lily - 2,405


                        Just pick something not in the top 5, it would be realistic, but not obviously stereotypical of the region.






                        share|improve this answer













                        I look for popular names, but not the MOST popular names. For example, I just googled "most popular names in the UK" and found this at the top link. An excerpt:



                        Boys



                        Oliver - 6,259
                        Harry - 5,031
                        George - 4,929
                        Noah - 4,273
                        Jack - 4,190
                        Jacob - 3,968
                        Leo - 3,781
                        Oscar - 3,739
                        Charlie - 3,724
                        Muhammad - 3,691


                        Girls



                        Olivia - 5,204
                        Amelia - 4,358
                        Isla - 3,373
                        Ava - 3,289
                        Emily - 3,121
                        Isabella - 2,627
                        Mia - 2,590
                        Poppy - 2,527
                        Ella - 2,452
                        Lily - 2,405


                        Just pick something not in the top 5, it would be realistic, but not obviously stereotypical of the region.







                        share|improve this answer












                        share|improve this answer



                        share|improve this answer










                        answered Mar 25 at 21:12









                        AmadeusAmadeus

                        59.5k677188




                        59.5k677188







                        • 9





                          Anyone else amused by the #1 names in both lists being the male and female equivalents of each other?

                          – Mason Wheeler
                          Mar 25 at 21:54






                        • 9





                          For extra credit: Consider the age of your character and use the "most popular" list of the correct year (or, at least, the correct "generation").

                          – Heinzi
                          Mar 26 at 10:46







                        • 3





                          @DoctorPenguin - Well, that list is for the entire UK, which of course includes Scotland. I suspect if you looked for one of just England you'd have different results. You could probably localize it even more, as I suspect that you won't see the same list from e.g. London vs. Liverpool, etc.

                          – Darrel Hoffman
                          Mar 26 at 13:58






                        • 2





                          My guess would be that although the Scottish population is smaller, the choice of names among that population is much less diverse, so some names bubble up just because they have less to choose from. This would be the same reason why Muhammed is so high up on the list - it's not just that there's a large percentage of Muslims living in the UK, it's that the diversity of names among Muslims is just generally much smaller than among other cultures. (I believe that Muhammed is the #1 most common name worldwide for that same reason.)

                          – Darrel Hoffman
                          Mar 26 at 14:24






                        • 1





                          @MasonWheeler, I was amused that OPs list of common names for each country were all the same name!

                          – Glen Yates
                          Mar 26 at 18:10












                        • 9





                          Anyone else amused by the #1 names in both lists being the male and female equivalents of each other?

                          – Mason Wheeler
                          Mar 25 at 21:54






                        • 9





                          For extra credit: Consider the age of your character and use the "most popular" list of the correct year (or, at least, the correct "generation").

                          – Heinzi
                          Mar 26 at 10:46







                        • 3





                          @DoctorPenguin - Well, that list is for the entire UK, which of course includes Scotland. I suspect if you looked for one of just England you'd have different results. You could probably localize it even more, as I suspect that you won't see the same list from e.g. London vs. Liverpool, etc.

                          – Darrel Hoffman
                          Mar 26 at 13:58






                        • 2





                          My guess would be that although the Scottish population is smaller, the choice of names among that population is much less diverse, so some names bubble up just because they have less to choose from. This would be the same reason why Muhammed is so high up on the list - it's not just that there's a large percentage of Muslims living in the UK, it's that the diversity of names among Muslims is just generally much smaller than among other cultures. (I believe that Muhammed is the #1 most common name worldwide for that same reason.)

                          – Darrel Hoffman
                          Mar 26 at 14:24






                        • 1





                          @MasonWheeler, I was amused that OPs list of common names for each country were all the same name!

                          – Glen Yates
                          Mar 26 at 18:10







                        9




                        9





                        Anyone else amused by the #1 names in both lists being the male and female equivalents of each other?

                        – Mason Wheeler
                        Mar 25 at 21:54





                        Anyone else amused by the #1 names in both lists being the male and female equivalents of each other?

                        – Mason Wheeler
                        Mar 25 at 21:54




                        9




                        9





                        For extra credit: Consider the age of your character and use the "most popular" list of the correct year (or, at least, the correct "generation").

                        – Heinzi
                        Mar 26 at 10:46






                        For extra credit: Consider the age of your character and use the "most popular" list of the correct year (or, at least, the correct "generation").

                        – Heinzi
                        Mar 26 at 10:46





                        3




                        3





                        @DoctorPenguin - Well, that list is for the entire UK, which of course includes Scotland. I suspect if you looked for one of just England you'd have different results. You could probably localize it even more, as I suspect that you won't see the same list from e.g. London vs. Liverpool, etc.

                        – Darrel Hoffman
                        Mar 26 at 13:58





                        @DoctorPenguin - Well, that list is for the entire UK, which of course includes Scotland. I suspect if you looked for one of just England you'd have different results. You could probably localize it even more, as I suspect that you won't see the same list from e.g. London vs. Liverpool, etc.

                        – Darrel Hoffman
                        Mar 26 at 13:58




                        2




                        2





                        My guess would be that although the Scottish population is smaller, the choice of names among that population is much less diverse, so some names bubble up just because they have less to choose from. This would be the same reason why Muhammed is so high up on the list - it's not just that there's a large percentage of Muslims living in the UK, it's that the diversity of names among Muslims is just generally much smaller than among other cultures. (I believe that Muhammed is the #1 most common name worldwide for that same reason.)

                        – Darrel Hoffman
                        Mar 26 at 14:24





                        My guess would be that although the Scottish population is smaller, the choice of names among that population is much less diverse, so some names bubble up just because they have less to choose from. This would be the same reason why Muhammed is so high up on the list - it's not just that there's a large percentage of Muslims living in the UK, it's that the diversity of names among Muslims is just generally much smaller than among other cultures. (I believe that Muhammed is the #1 most common name worldwide for that same reason.)

                        – Darrel Hoffman
                        Mar 26 at 14:24




                        1




                        1





                        @MasonWheeler, I was amused that OPs list of common names for each country were all the same name!

                        – Glen Yates
                        Mar 26 at 18:10





                        @MasonWheeler, I was amused that OPs list of common names for each country were all the same name!

                        – Glen Yates
                        Mar 26 at 18:10











                        5














                        The problem about this is that most of the time we want to read something about special people. Sure, we want to be able to sympathize with the character and for example superhero comics have a history of making it look like everyone could be Superman - or Shazam the 14-year-old-boy-transformed-into-a-superhero - but characters in books, comics, etc. tend to be special in some regards. By giving your protagonist a name that seemingly every second person has they can appear quite boring.



                        What name do you think would be more memorable: "Shazam" or "Billy"?



                        Yes, the protagonist in the linked comic series is named "Billy", quite the typical name. But most people will likely find his superhero form more memorable. Maybe you could use this and give your "Juan" and "Maria" interesting and memorable nicknames. Especially if they have a name that seemingly everyone else around them had that could be a reason to try and stand out. How do your characters feel about their name? Do they like this typical name? Maybe they like the feeling of proudly representing the majority. Or maybe they want to be special. Different. Not just another "Juan" or "Maria".



                        A lot of this depends on the setting. In fantasy or sci-fi settings it's far easier to just come up with new names. In modern day settings like in a thriller you will more likely use "normal" names. But this also depends on a lot of factors. Are you in a rural area where older names are more present? Or a metropolitan city with influences from all around the globe? Is the social class of your characters focused on traditions or innovation?



                        As you mention that you have a setting with lots of people from all over the world you could use steretypical names a few times. Maybe one or two out of a group of five people would feel like something that can actually happen while still not feeling as if you were simply too lazy to look up other names. But you should think about other options to refer to these characters and you should think about how the characters feel about their own names.






                        share|improve this answer























                        • Of course at this point with genre expectations, "Billy the superhero" would actually be unusual and memorable, like "Bob the stone troll" or "Tim the enchanter". Would also indicate a comic lean, though.

                          – StarWeaver
                          Mar 26 at 16:37















                        5














                        The problem about this is that most of the time we want to read something about special people. Sure, we want to be able to sympathize with the character and for example superhero comics have a history of making it look like everyone could be Superman - or Shazam the 14-year-old-boy-transformed-into-a-superhero - but characters in books, comics, etc. tend to be special in some regards. By giving your protagonist a name that seemingly every second person has they can appear quite boring.



                        What name do you think would be more memorable: "Shazam" or "Billy"?



                        Yes, the protagonist in the linked comic series is named "Billy", quite the typical name. But most people will likely find his superhero form more memorable. Maybe you could use this and give your "Juan" and "Maria" interesting and memorable nicknames. Especially if they have a name that seemingly everyone else around them had that could be a reason to try and stand out. How do your characters feel about their name? Do they like this typical name? Maybe they like the feeling of proudly representing the majority. Or maybe they want to be special. Different. Not just another "Juan" or "Maria".



                        A lot of this depends on the setting. In fantasy or sci-fi settings it's far easier to just come up with new names. In modern day settings like in a thriller you will more likely use "normal" names. But this also depends on a lot of factors. Are you in a rural area where older names are more present? Or a metropolitan city with influences from all around the globe? Is the social class of your characters focused on traditions or innovation?



                        As you mention that you have a setting with lots of people from all over the world you could use steretypical names a few times. Maybe one or two out of a group of five people would feel like something that can actually happen while still not feeling as if you were simply too lazy to look up other names. But you should think about other options to refer to these characters and you should think about how the characters feel about their own names.






                        share|improve this answer























                        • Of course at this point with genre expectations, "Billy the superhero" would actually be unusual and memorable, like "Bob the stone troll" or "Tim the enchanter". Would also indicate a comic lean, though.

                          – StarWeaver
                          Mar 26 at 16:37













                        5












                        5








                        5







                        The problem about this is that most of the time we want to read something about special people. Sure, we want to be able to sympathize with the character and for example superhero comics have a history of making it look like everyone could be Superman - or Shazam the 14-year-old-boy-transformed-into-a-superhero - but characters in books, comics, etc. tend to be special in some regards. By giving your protagonist a name that seemingly every second person has they can appear quite boring.



                        What name do you think would be more memorable: "Shazam" or "Billy"?



                        Yes, the protagonist in the linked comic series is named "Billy", quite the typical name. But most people will likely find his superhero form more memorable. Maybe you could use this and give your "Juan" and "Maria" interesting and memorable nicknames. Especially if they have a name that seemingly everyone else around them had that could be a reason to try and stand out. How do your characters feel about their name? Do they like this typical name? Maybe they like the feeling of proudly representing the majority. Or maybe they want to be special. Different. Not just another "Juan" or "Maria".



                        A lot of this depends on the setting. In fantasy or sci-fi settings it's far easier to just come up with new names. In modern day settings like in a thriller you will more likely use "normal" names. But this also depends on a lot of factors. Are you in a rural area where older names are more present? Or a metropolitan city with influences from all around the globe? Is the social class of your characters focused on traditions or innovation?



                        As you mention that you have a setting with lots of people from all over the world you could use steretypical names a few times. Maybe one or two out of a group of five people would feel like something that can actually happen while still not feeling as if you were simply too lazy to look up other names. But you should think about other options to refer to these characters and you should think about how the characters feel about their own names.






                        share|improve this answer













                        The problem about this is that most of the time we want to read something about special people. Sure, we want to be able to sympathize with the character and for example superhero comics have a history of making it look like everyone could be Superman - or Shazam the 14-year-old-boy-transformed-into-a-superhero - but characters in books, comics, etc. tend to be special in some regards. By giving your protagonist a name that seemingly every second person has they can appear quite boring.



                        What name do you think would be more memorable: "Shazam" or "Billy"?



                        Yes, the protagonist in the linked comic series is named "Billy", quite the typical name. But most people will likely find his superhero form more memorable. Maybe you could use this and give your "Juan" and "Maria" interesting and memorable nicknames. Especially if they have a name that seemingly everyone else around them had that could be a reason to try and stand out. How do your characters feel about their name? Do they like this typical name? Maybe they like the feeling of proudly representing the majority. Or maybe they want to be special. Different. Not just another "Juan" or "Maria".



                        A lot of this depends on the setting. In fantasy or sci-fi settings it's far easier to just come up with new names. In modern day settings like in a thriller you will more likely use "normal" names. But this also depends on a lot of factors. Are you in a rural area where older names are more present? Or a metropolitan city with influences from all around the globe? Is the social class of your characters focused on traditions or innovation?



                        As you mention that you have a setting with lots of people from all over the world you could use steretypical names a few times. Maybe one or two out of a group of five people would feel like something that can actually happen while still not feeling as if you were simply too lazy to look up other names. But you should think about other options to refer to these characters and you should think about how the characters feel about their own names.







                        share|improve this answer












                        share|improve this answer



                        share|improve this answer










                        answered Mar 25 at 20:53









                        SecespitusSecespitus

                        5,46733376




                        5,46733376












                        • Of course at this point with genre expectations, "Billy the superhero" would actually be unusual and memorable, like "Bob the stone troll" or "Tim the enchanter". Would also indicate a comic lean, though.

                          – StarWeaver
                          Mar 26 at 16:37

















                        • Of course at this point with genre expectations, "Billy the superhero" would actually be unusual and memorable, like "Bob the stone troll" or "Tim the enchanter". Would also indicate a comic lean, though.

                          – StarWeaver
                          Mar 26 at 16:37
















                        Of course at this point with genre expectations, "Billy the superhero" would actually be unusual and memorable, like "Bob the stone troll" or "Tim the enchanter". Would also indicate a comic lean, though.

                        – StarWeaver
                        Mar 26 at 16:37





                        Of course at this point with genre expectations, "Billy the superhero" would actually be unusual and memorable, like "Bob the stone troll" or "Tim the enchanter". Would also indicate a comic lean, though.

                        – StarWeaver
                        Mar 26 at 16:37











                        5














                        It is bad when your "national" character is one-dimensional. It is perfectly fine when this character is non-stereotypical.



                        Creating a "representative" characters with stereotypical names is a bad (and well-worn) practice when those characters also reinforce popular stereotypes of a certain nation or racial group. On the other hand, if such character has depth and well-developed, steretotypical name becomes insignificant.



                        This trope was humorously subverted in the 2002 movie The Cuckoo, in which one of the main characters, a Russian, has name "Ivan", but his newfound friend, Finnish sniper Veikko is not believing it because




                        when they first met and Veikko asks for Ivan's name, Ivan replies "Get lost!" (in Russian) - and this is how Veikko had called him ever since.







                        share|improve this answer





























                          5














                          It is bad when your "national" character is one-dimensional. It is perfectly fine when this character is non-stereotypical.



                          Creating a "representative" characters with stereotypical names is a bad (and well-worn) practice when those characters also reinforce popular stereotypes of a certain nation or racial group. On the other hand, if such character has depth and well-developed, steretotypical name becomes insignificant.



                          This trope was humorously subverted in the 2002 movie The Cuckoo, in which one of the main characters, a Russian, has name "Ivan", but his newfound friend, Finnish sniper Veikko is not believing it because




                          when they first met and Veikko asks for Ivan's name, Ivan replies "Get lost!" (in Russian) - and this is how Veikko had called him ever since.







                          share|improve this answer



























                            5












                            5








                            5







                            It is bad when your "national" character is one-dimensional. It is perfectly fine when this character is non-stereotypical.



                            Creating a "representative" characters with stereotypical names is a bad (and well-worn) practice when those characters also reinforce popular stereotypes of a certain nation or racial group. On the other hand, if such character has depth and well-developed, steretotypical name becomes insignificant.



                            This trope was humorously subverted in the 2002 movie The Cuckoo, in which one of the main characters, a Russian, has name "Ivan", but his newfound friend, Finnish sniper Veikko is not believing it because




                            when they first met and Veikko asks for Ivan's name, Ivan replies "Get lost!" (in Russian) - and this is how Veikko had called him ever since.







                            share|improve this answer















                            It is bad when your "national" character is one-dimensional. It is perfectly fine when this character is non-stereotypical.



                            Creating a "representative" characters with stereotypical names is a bad (and well-worn) practice when those characters also reinforce popular stereotypes of a certain nation or racial group. On the other hand, if such character has depth and well-developed, steretotypical name becomes insignificant.



                            This trope was humorously subverted in the 2002 movie The Cuckoo, in which one of the main characters, a Russian, has name "Ivan", but his newfound friend, Finnish sniper Veikko is not believing it because




                            when they first met and Veikko asks for Ivan's name, Ivan replies "Get lost!" (in Russian) - and this is how Veikko had called him ever since.








                            share|improve this answer














                            share|improve this answer



                            share|improve this answer








                            edited Mar 25 at 21:27

























                            answered Mar 25 at 21:17









                            AlexanderAlexander

                            3,700413




                            3,700413





















                                5














                                It depends on what sort of story you want to write.



                                If you want your character to stand out (superhero, famous outlaw, rebel leader, etc.) it's probably better to pick a name that stands out.



                                If you're trying to show that this is an ordinary person, living an ordinary life, then using something more common can be an effective tool. Think of Winston Smith from 1984 - his last name's meant to sound like a generic, boring British guy. There's nothing particularly remarkable about him. He's a guy who tries to rebel and fails.



                                A generic name can also be an alias meant to make an interesting character sound less remarkable (spy, secret agent, etc.). For example, John Reese in the TV show Person of Interest.



                                There's the humor angle, too. Maybe you're writing about some poor guy named "John Doe" that no one can take seriously.






                                share|improve this answer



























                                  5














                                  It depends on what sort of story you want to write.



                                  If you want your character to stand out (superhero, famous outlaw, rebel leader, etc.) it's probably better to pick a name that stands out.



                                  If you're trying to show that this is an ordinary person, living an ordinary life, then using something more common can be an effective tool. Think of Winston Smith from 1984 - his last name's meant to sound like a generic, boring British guy. There's nothing particularly remarkable about him. He's a guy who tries to rebel and fails.



                                  A generic name can also be an alias meant to make an interesting character sound less remarkable (spy, secret agent, etc.). For example, John Reese in the TV show Person of Interest.



                                  There's the humor angle, too. Maybe you're writing about some poor guy named "John Doe" that no one can take seriously.






                                  share|improve this answer

























                                    5












                                    5








                                    5







                                    It depends on what sort of story you want to write.



                                    If you want your character to stand out (superhero, famous outlaw, rebel leader, etc.) it's probably better to pick a name that stands out.



                                    If you're trying to show that this is an ordinary person, living an ordinary life, then using something more common can be an effective tool. Think of Winston Smith from 1984 - his last name's meant to sound like a generic, boring British guy. There's nothing particularly remarkable about him. He's a guy who tries to rebel and fails.



                                    A generic name can also be an alias meant to make an interesting character sound less remarkable (spy, secret agent, etc.). For example, John Reese in the TV show Person of Interest.



                                    There's the humor angle, too. Maybe you're writing about some poor guy named "John Doe" that no one can take seriously.






                                    share|improve this answer













                                    It depends on what sort of story you want to write.



                                    If you want your character to stand out (superhero, famous outlaw, rebel leader, etc.) it's probably better to pick a name that stands out.



                                    If you're trying to show that this is an ordinary person, living an ordinary life, then using something more common can be an effective tool. Think of Winston Smith from 1984 - his last name's meant to sound like a generic, boring British guy. There's nothing particularly remarkable about him. He's a guy who tries to rebel and fails.



                                    A generic name can also be an alias meant to make an interesting character sound less remarkable (spy, secret agent, etc.). For example, John Reese in the TV show Person of Interest.



                                    There's the humor angle, too. Maybe you're writing about some poor guy named "John Doe" that no one can take seriously.







                                    share|improve this answer












                                    share|improve this answer



                                    share|improve this answer










                                    answered Mar 25 at 22:03









                                    Evil SparrowEvil Sparrow

                                    1,310516




                                    1,310516





















                                        3














                                        There is nothing wrong with using common names for characters unless you over use them. If everyone has the most common names for their region, the readers may start paying attention to that instead of your story.



                                        That being said, there are ways of playing with it. You could use it to break expectations. Maybe Ivan is from the UK?



                                        Heck, any of them could be from the US.



                                        Maybe have two characters named John. One will end up being called by a nickname. My name isn't incredibly common but for one event we had five people with my first name on a radio net. That was a fun mess. With 95 people on the radio net, last names were out as well.



                                        Maybe have John meet Juan. Having the "same" name might be a running gag for the two.






                                        share|improve this answer



























                                          3














                                          There is nothing wrong with using common names for characters unless you over use them. If everyone has the most common names for their region, the readers may start paying attention to that instead of your story.



                                          That being said, there are ways of playing with it. You could use it to break expectations. Maybe Ivan is from the UK?



                                          Heck, any of them could be from the US.



                                          Maybe have two characters named John. One will end up being called by a nickname. My name isn't incredibly common but for one event we had five people with my first name on a radio net. That was a fun mess. With 95 people on the radio net, last names were out as well.



                                          Maybe have John meet Juan. Having the "same" name might be a running gag for the two.






                                          share|improve this answer

























                                            3












                                            3








                                            3







                                            There is nothing wrong with using common names for characters unless you over use them. If everyone has the most common names for their region, the readers may start paying attention to that instead of your story.



                                            That being said, there are ways of playing with it. You could use it to break expectations. Maybe Ivan is from the UK?



                                            Heck, any of them could be from the US.



                                            Maybe have two characters named John. One will end up being called by a nickname. My name isn't incredibly common but for one event we had five people with my first name on a radio net. That was a fun mess. With 95 people on the radio net, last names were out as well.



                                            Maybe have John meet Juan. Having the "same" name might be a running gag for the two.






                                            share|improve this answer













                                            There is nothing wrong with using common names for characters unless you over use them. If everyone has the most common names for their region, the readers may start paying attention to that instead of your story.



                                            That being said, there are ways of playing with it. You could use it to break expectations. Maybe Ivan is from the UK?



                                            Heck, any of them could be from the US.



                                            Maybe have two characters named John. One will end up being called by a nickname. My name isn't incredibly common but for one event we had five people with my first name on a radio net. That was a fun mess. With 95 people on the radio net, last names were out as well.



                                            Maybe have John meet Juan. Having the "same" name might be a running gag for the two.







                                            share|improve this answer












                                            share|improve this answer



                                            share|improve this answer










                                            answered Mar 25 at 20:53









                                            ShadoCatShadoCat

                                            78116




                                            78116





















                                                3














                                                Just to point out, that the names John, Juan, and Ivan (along with the Irish Sean/Shane, Scottish Ian, the French Jean, the Italian Giovanni, the German Hans and many others) are derivations of the Hebrew name Yohanna which means Yahweh (God) is Gracious. Many of the most common Middle-East and European names are derived from Biblical names. John is so common that I'm not sure if you realized that the names you selected are all John-equivalents.



                                                Non-Sterotypical Names tend to be Americans in fiction from outside the United States (If you've watched any BBC shows, like Doctor Who or Top Gear, when an American appears, expect someone to guess their American from the name alone, because it's a weird one). America, being a melting pot culture, could have a odd cultural mashup of names that could be because they are a mixed nationality family following a traditional naming convention (Irish families tend to name first born son in a convention that the first name is the child's paternal Grandfather, second name is child's maternal Grandfather, family name... if an Irish man marries a Hispanic woman, than the name could be Sean Roberto O'Reilly... and that's not assuming that they can always give the kid a Russian name for no reason beyond wanting to be different).



                                                European names to Americans tend to be stereotypical because, well, an English family is going to name their kids English Names, and the French Families are going to give their kids French Names, and the German kids will be given German Names. And each society tends to have rules about naming their kids too.






                                                share|improve this answer



























                                                  3














                                                  Just to point out, that the names John, Juan, and Ivan (along with the Irish Sean/Shane, Scottish Ian, the French Jean, the Italian Giovanni, the German Hans and many others) are derivations of the Hebrew name Yohanna which means Yahweh (God) is Gracious. Many of the most common Middle-East and European names are derived from Biblical names. John is so common that I'm not sure if you realized that the names you selected are all John-equivalents.



                                                  Non-Sterotypical Names tend to be Americans in fiction from outside the United States (If you've watched any BBC shows, like Doctor Who or Top Gear, when an American appears, expect someone to guess their American from the name alone, because it's a weird one). America, being a melting pot culture, could have a odd cultural mashup of names that could be because they are a mixed nationality family following a traditional naming convention (Irish families tend to name first born son in a convention that the first name is the child's paternal Grandfather, second name is child's maternal Grandfather, family name... if an Irish man marries a Hispanic woman, than the name could be Sean Roberto O'Reilly... and that's not assuming that they can always give the kid a Russian name for no reason beyond wanting to be different).



                                                  European names to Americans tend to be stereotypical because, well, an English family is going to name their kids English Names, and the French Families are going to give their kids French Names, and the German kids will be given German Names. And each society tends to have rules about naming their kids too.






                                                  share|improve this answer

























                                                    3












                                                    3








                                                    3







                                                    Just to point out, that the names John, Juan, and Ivan (along with the Irish Sean/Shane, Scottish Ian, the French Jean, the Italian Giovanni, the German Hans and many others) are derivations of the Hebrew name Yohanna which means Yahweh (God) is Gracious. Many of the most common Middle-East and European names are derived from Biblical names. John is so common that I'm not sure if you realized that the names you selected are all John-equivalents.



                                                    Non-Sterotypical Names tend to be Americans in fiction from outside the United States (If you've watched any BBC shows, like Doctor Who or Top Gear, when an American appears, expect someone to guess their American from the name alone, because it's a weird one). America, being a melting pot culture, could have a odd cultural mashup of names that could be because they are a mixed nationality family following a traditional naming convention (Irish families tend to name first born son in a convention that the first name is the child's paternal Grandfather, second name is child's maternal Grandfather, family name... if an Irish man marries a Hispanic woman, than the name could be Sean Roberto O'Reilly... and that's not assuming that they can always give the kid a Russian name for no reason beyond wanting to be different).



                                                    European names to Americans tend to be stereotypical because, well, an English family is going to name their kids English Names, and the French Families are going to give their kids French Names, and the German kids will be given German Names. And each society tends to have rules about naming their kids too.






                                                    share|improve this answer













                                                    Just to point out, that the names John, Juan, and Ivan (along with the Irish Sean/Shane, Scottish Ian, the French Jean, the Italian Giovanni, the German Hans and many others) are derivations of the Hebrew name Yohanna which means Yahweh (God) is Gracious. Many of the most common Middle-East and European names are derived from Biblical names. John is so common that I'm not sure if you realized that the names you selected are all John-equivalents.



                                                    Non-Sterotypical Names tend to be Americans in fiction from outside the United States (If you've watched any BBC shows, like Doctor Who or Top Gear, when an American appears, expect someone to guess their American from the name alone, because it's a weird one). America, being a melting pot culture, could have a odd cultural mashup of names that could be because they are a mixed nationality family following a traditional naming convention (Irish families tend to name first born son in a convention that the first name is the child's paternal Grandfather, second name is child's maternal Grandfather, family name... if an Irish man marries a Hispanic woman, than the name could be Sean Roberto O'Reilly... and that's not assuming that they can always give the kid a Russian name for no reason beyond wanting to be different).



                                                    European names to Americans tend to be stereotypical because, well, an English family is going to name their kids English Names, and the French Families are going to give their kids French Names, and the German kids will be given German Names. And each society tends to have rules about naming their kids too.







                                                    share|improve this answer












                                                    share|improve this answer



                                                    share|improve this answer










                                                    answered Mar 26 at 14:33









                                                    hszmvhszmv

                                                    4,052111




                                                    4,052111





















                                                        3














                                                        If you look at any group of people, some will have very common names, others well known but less common names, and a few will have unusual names. If your own characters also have a mix, you're fine. You don't want all unusual names or your reader will have trouble remember them. If they're all top names, that isn't realistic (the top names aren't the majority of names).



                                                        Most of my modern-day characters have well-known names because the rest of my characters are from ancient times, in other parts of the world, and their names are unusual. So I needed a balance.



                                                        If you're careful that the common names you choose are actually popular in the real life setting you're taking them from and not stereotypes elsewhere, you're reasonably okay. This is hard to suss out but one example could be Juan in the United States, even though it's a real name here and in countries that are majority Spanish-speaking. (Note: If you're American and old enough to remember certain coffee commercials (though that's not the only source of the the stereotype), you probably see my point.) Just like you'd want to avoid making the only Jewish characters in a story Abraham and Sarah (unless of course it's a Bible retelling).



                                                        I would also avoid making all the names from a region super common ones, even if they're not stereotypes. Why make readers from those countries or with that ancestry wonder why the other characters are so much more interesting?






                                                        share|improve this answer



























                                                          3














                                                          If you look at any group of people, some will have very common names, others well known but less common names, and a few will have unusual names. If your own characters also have a mix, you're fine. You don't want all unusual names or your reader will have trouble remember them. If they're all top names, that isn't realistic (the top names aren't the majority of names).



                                                          Most of my modern-day characters have well-known names because the rest of my characters are from ancient times, in other parts of the world, and their names are unusual. So I needed a balance.



                                                          If you're careful that the common names you choose are actually popular in the real life setting you're taking them from and not stereotypes elsewhere, you're reasonably okay. This is hard to suss out but one example could be Juan in the United States, even though it's a real name here and in countries that are majority Spanish-speaking. (Note: If you're American and old enough to remember certain coffee commercials (though that's not the only source of the the stereotype), you probably see my point.) Just like you'd want to avoid making the only Jewish characters in a story Abraham and Sarah (unless of course it's a Bible retelling).



                                                          I would also avoid making all the names from a region super common ones, even if they're not stereotypes. Why make readers from those countries or with that ancestry wonder why the other characters are so much more interesting?






                                                          share|improve this answer

























                                                            3












                                                            3








                                                            3







                                                            If you look at any group of people, some will have very common names, others well known but less common names, and a few will have unusual names. If your own characters also have a mix, you're fine. You don't want all unusual names or your reader will have trouble remember them. If they're all top names, that isn't realistic (the top names aren't the majority of names).



                                                            Most of my modern-day characters have well-known names because the rest of my characters are from ancient times, in other parts of the world, and their names are unusual. So I needed a balance.



                                                            If you're careful that the common names you choose are actually popular in the real life setting you're taking them from and not stereotypes elsewhere, you're reasonably okay. This is hard to suss out but one example could be Juan in the United States, even though it's a real name here and in countries that are majority Spanish-speaking. (Note: If you're American and old enough to remember certain coffee commercials (though that's not the only source of the the stereotype), you probably see my point.) Just like you'd want to avoid making the only Jewish characters in a story Abraham and Sarah (unless of course it's a Bible retelling).



                                                            I would also avoid making all the names from a region super common ones, even if they're not stereotypes. Why make readers from those countries or with that ancestry wonder why the other characters are so much more interesting?






                                                            share|improve this answer













                                                            If you look at any group of people, some will have very common names, others well known but less common names, and a few will have unusual names. If your own characters also have a mix, you're fine. You don't want all unusual names or your reader will have trouble remember them. If they're all top names, that isn't realistic (the top names aren't the majority of names).



                                                            Most of my modern-day characters have well-known names because the rest of my characters are from ancient times, in other parts of the world, and their names are unusual. So I needed a balance.



                                                            If you're careful that the common names you choose are actually popular in the real life setting you're taking them from and not stereotypes elsewhere, you're reasonably okay. This is hard to suss out but one example could be Juan in the United States, even though it's a real name here and in countries that are majority Spanish-speaking. (Note: If you're American and old enough to remember certain coffee commercials (though that's not the only source of the the stereotype), you probably see my point.) Just like you'd want to avoid making the only Jewish characters in a story Abraham and Sarah (unless of course it's a Bible retelling).



                                                            I would also avoid making all the names from a region super common ones, even if they're not stereotypes. Why make readers from those countries or with that ancestry wonder why the other characters are so much more interesting?







                                                            share|improve this answer












                                                            share|improve this answer



                                                            share|improve this answer










                                                            answered Mar 27 at 1:49









                                                            CynCyn

                                                            18.5k14087




                                                            18.5k14087





















                                                                3














                                                                Choose names that have that countries "feel" with out being stereotypical (e.g. Alejandro -Mexico, or Aleksandr -Russia)



                                                                As I interpret it, your main aim is to have the character's country of origin obvious from their name ("strong sense of location with the names"). Stereotypical names will obviously do that, but as others have pointed out, these names may not even be popular in this day and age and having too many stereotypical names may make the story and characters seem less... complex?



                                                                So why not look up names online and pick ones that are not stereotypical names but still have that countries "feel" to them. For example when I look up Mexican girls names I see that Maria is number one (and very stereotypical) but plenty of the others "feel" Mexican without me ever having heard the name before (or rarely): Juana, Margarita, Verónica, Alejandra, María Elena...



                                                                You could also just pick a common name (e.g. Alexander) and look up that name in Spanish or Russian (Alejandro -Spanish, Aleksandr -Russia). Again I've never met an Alejandro or an Aleksandr but I could give you a good guess as to what part of the world their name is from.






                                                                share|improve this answer



























                                                                  3














                                                                  Choose names that have that countries "feel" with out being stereotypical (e.g. Alejandro -Mexico, or Aleksandr -Russia)



                                                                  As I interpret it, your main aim is to have the character's country of origin obvious from their name ("strong sense of location with the names"). Stereotypical names will obviously do that, but as others have pointed out, these names may not even be popular in this day and age and having too many stereotypical names may make the story and characters seem less... complex?



                                                                  So why not look up names online and pick ones that are not stereotypical names but still have that countries "feel" to them. For example when I look up Mexican girls names I see that Maria is number one (and very stereotypical) but plenty of the others "feel" Mexican without me ever having heard the name before (or rarely): Juana, Margarita, Verónica, Alejandra, María Elena...



                                                                  You could also just pick a common name (e.g. Alexander) and look up that name in Spanish or Russian (Alejandro -Spanish, Aleksandr -Russia). Again I've never met an Alejandro or an Aleksandr but I could give you a good guess as to what part of the world their name is from.






                                                                  share|improve this answer

























                                                                    3












                                                                    3








                                                                    3







                                                                    Choose names that have that countries "feel" with out being stereotypical (e.g. Alejandro -Mexico, or Aleksandr -Russia)



                                                                    As I interpret it, your main aim is to have the character's country of origin obvious from their name ("strong sense of location with the names"). Stereotypical names will obviously do that, but as others have pointed out, these names may not even be popular in this day and age and having too many stereotypical names may make the story and characters seem less... complex?



                                                                    So why not look up names online and pick ones that are not stereotypical names but still have that countries "feel" to them. For example when I look up Mexican girls names I see that Maria is number one (and very stereotypical) but plenty of the others "feel" Mexican without me ever having heard the name before (or rarely): Juana, Margarita, Verónica, Alejandra, María Elena...



                                                                    You could also just pick a common name (e.g. Alexander) and look up that name in Spanish or Russian (Alejandro -Spanish, Aleksandr -Russia). Again I've never met an Alejandro or an Aleksandr but I could give you a good guess as to what part of the world their name is from.






                                                                    share|improve this answer













                                                                    Choose names that have that countries "feel" with out being stereotypical (e.g. Alejandro -Mexico, or Aleksandr -Russia)



                                                                    As I interpret it, your main aim is to have the character's country of origin obvious from their name ("strong sense of location with the names"). Stereotypical names will obviously do that, but as others have pointed out, these names may not even be popular in this day and age and having too many stereotypical names may make the story and characters seem less... complex?



                                                                    So why not look up names online and pick ones that are not stereotypical names but still have that countries "feel" to them. For example when I look up Mexican girls names I see that Maria is number one (and very stereotypical) but plenty of the others "feel" Mexican without me ever having heard the name before (or rarely): Juana, Margarita, Verónica, Alejandra, María Elena...



                                                                    You could also just pick a common name (e.g. Alexander) and look up that name in Spanish or Russian (Alejandro -Spanish, Aleksandr -Russia). Again I've never met an Alejandro or an Aleksandr but I could give you a good guess as to what part of the world their name is from.







                                                                    share|improve this answer












                                                                    share|improve this answer



                                                                    share|improve this answer










                                                                    answered Mar 27 at 3:15









                                                                    B.KenobiB.Kenobi

                                                                    1813




                                                                    1813



























                                                                        draft saved

                                                                        draft discarded
















































                                                                        Thanks for contributing an answer to Writing Stack Exchange!


                                                                        • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                                                                        But avoid


                                                                        • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                                                                        • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.

                                                                        To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




                                                                        draft saved


                                                                        draft discarded














                                                                        StackExchange.ready(
                                                                        function ()
                                                                        StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fwriting.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f44023%2fstereotypical-names%23new-answer', 'question_page');

                                                                        );

                                                                        Post as a guest















                                                                        Required, but never shown





















































                                                                        Required, but never shown














                                                                        Required, but never shown












                                                                        Required, but never shown







                                                                        Required, but never shown

































                                                                        Required, but never shown














                                                                        Required, but never shown












                                                                        Required, but never shown







                                                                        Required, but never shown







                                                                        Popular posts from this blog

                                                                        Færeyskur hestur Heimild | Tengill | Tilvísanir | LeiðsagnarvalRossið - síða um færeyska hrossið á færeyskuGott ár hjá færeyska hestinum

                                                                        He _____ here since 1970 . Answer needed [closed]What does “since he was so high” mean?Meaning of “catch birds for”?How do I ensure “since” takes the meaning I want?“Who cares here” meaningWhat does “right round toward” mean?the time tense (had now been detected)What does the phrase “ring around the roses” mean here?Correct usage of “visited upon”Meaning of “foiled rail sabotage bid”It was the third time I had gone to Rome or It is the third time I had been to Rome

                                                                        Slayer Innehåll Historia | Stil, komposition och lyrik | Bandets betydelse och framgångar | Sidoprojekt och samarbeten | Kontroverser | Medlemmar | Utmärkelser och nomineringar | Turnéer och festivaler | Diskografi | Referenser | Externa länkar | Navigeringsmenywww.slayer.net”Metal Massacre vol. 1””Metal Massacre vol. 3””Metal Massacre Volume III””Show No Mercy””Haunting the Chapel””Live Undead””Hell Awaits””Reign in Blood””Reign in Blood””Gold & Platinum – Reign in Blood””Golden Gods Awards Winners”originalet”Kerrang! Hall Of Fame””Slayer Looks Back On 37-Year Career In New Video Series: Part Two””South of Heaven””Gold & Platinum – South of Heaven””Seasons in the Abyss””Gold & Platinum - Seasons in the Abyss””Divine Intervention””Divine Intervention - Release group by Slayer””Gold & Platinum - Divine Intervention””Live Intrusion””Undisputed Attitude””Abolish Government/Superficial Love””Release “Slatanic Slaughter: A Tribute to Slayer” by Various Artists””Diabolus in Musica””Soundtrack to the Apocalypse””God Hates Us All””Systematic - Relationships””War at the Warfield””Gold & Platinum - War at the Warfield””Soundtrack to the Apocalypse””Gold & Platinum - Still Reigning””Metallica, Slayer, Iron Mauden Among Winners At Metal Hammer Awards””Eternal Pyre””Eternal Pyre - Slayer release group””Eternal Pyre””Metal Storm Awards 2006””Kerrang! Hall Of Fame””Slayer Wins 'Best Metal' Grammy Award””Slayer Guitarist Jeff Hanneman Dies””Bullet-For My Valentine booed at Metal Hammer Golden Gods Awards””Unholy Aliance””The End Of Slayer?””Slayer: We Could Thrash Out Two More Albums If We're Fast Enough...””'The Unholy Alliance: Chapter III' UK Dates Added”originalet”Megadeth And Slayer To Co-Headline 'Canadian Carnage' Trek”originalet”World Painted Blood””Release “World Painted Blood” by Slayer””Metallica Heading To Cinemas””Slayer, Megadeth To Join Forces For 'European Carnage' Tour - Dec. 18, 2010”originalet”Slayer's Hanneman Contracts Acute Infection; Band To Bring In Guest Guitarist””Cannibal Corpse's Pat O'Brien Will Step In As Slayer's Guest Guitarist”originalet”Slayer’s Jeff Hanneman Dead at 49””Dave Lombardo Says He Made Only $67,000 In 2011 While Touring With Slayer””Slayer: We Do Not Agree With Dave Lombardo's Substance Or Timeline Of Events””Slayer Welcomes Drummer Paul Bostaph Back To The Fold””Slayer Hope to Unveil Never-Before-Heard Jeff Hanneman Material on Next Album””Slayer Debut New Song 'Implode' During Surprise Golden Gods Appearance””Release group Repentless by Slayer””Repentless - Slayer - Credits””Slayer””Metal Storm Awards 2015””Slayer - to release comic book "Repentless #1"””Slayer To Release 'Repentless' 6.66" Vinyl Box Set””BREAKING NEWS: Slayer Announce Farewell Tour””Slayer Recruit Lamb of God, Anthrax, Behemoth + Testament for Final Tour””Slayer lägger ner efter 37 år””Slayer Announces Second North American Leg Of 'Final' Tour””Final World Tour””Slayer Announces Final European Tour With Lamb of God, Anthrax And Obituary””Slayer To Tour Europe With Lamb of God, Anthrax And Obituary””Slayer To Play 'Last French Show Ever' At Next Year's Hellfst””Slayer's Final World Tour Will Extend Into 2019””Death Angel's Rob Cavestany On Slayer's 'Farewell' Tour: 'Some Of Us Could See This Coming'””Testament Has No Plans To Retire Anytime Soon, Says Chuck Billy””Anthrax's Scott Ian On Slayer's 'Farewell' Tour Plans: 'I Was Surprised And I Wasn't Surprised'””Slayer””Slayer's Morbid Schlock””Review/Rock; For Slayer, the Mania Is the Message””Slayer - Biography””Slayer - Reign In Blood”originalet”Dave Lombardo””An exclusive oral history of Slayer”originalet”Exclusive! Interview With Slayer Guitarist Jeff Hanneman”originalet”Thinking Out Loud: Slayer's Kerry King on hair metal, Satan and being polite””Slayer Lyrics””Slayer - Biography””Most influential artists for extreme metal music””Slayer - Reign in Blood””Slayer guitarist Jeff Hanneman dies aged 49””Slatanic Slaughter: A Tribute to Slayer””Gateway to Hell: A Tribute to Slayer””Covered In Blood””Slayer: The Origins of Thrash in San Francisco, CA.””Why They Rule - #6 Slayer”originalet”Guitar World's 100 Greatest Heavy Metal Guitarists Of All Time”originalet”The fans have spoken: Slayer comes out on top in readers' polls”originalet”Tribute to Jeff Hanneman (1964-2013)””Lamb Of God Frontman: We Sound Like A Slayer Rip-Off””BEHEMOTH Frontman Pays Tribute To SLAYER's JEFF HANNEMAN””Slayer, Hatebreed Doing Double Duty On This Year's Ozzfest””System of a Down””Lacuna Coil’s Andrea Ferro Talks Influences, Skateboarding, Band Origins + More””Slayer - Reign in Blood””Into The Lungs of Hell””Slayer rules - en utställning om fans””Slayer and Their Fans Slashed Through a No-Holds-Barred Night at Gas Monkey””Home””Slayer””Gold & Platinum - The Big 4 Live from Sofia, Bulgaria””Exclusive! Interview With Slayer Guitarist Kerry King””2008-02-23: Wiltern, Los Angeles, CA, USA””Slayer's Kerry King To Perform With Megadeth Tonight! - Oct. 21, 2010”originalet”Dave Lombardo - Biography”Slayer Case DismissedArkiveradUltimate Classic Rock: Slayer guitarist Jeff Hanneman dead at 49.”Slayer: "We could never do any thing like Some Kind Of Monster..."””Cannibal Corpse'S Pat O'Brien Will Step In As Slayer'S Guest Guitarist | The Official Slayer Site”originalet”Slayer Wins 'Best Metal' Grammy Award””Slayer Guitarist Jeff Hanneman Dies””Kerrang! Awards 2006 Blog: Kerrang! Hall Of Fame””Kerrang! Awards 2013: Kerrang! Legend”originalet”Metallica, Slayer, Iron Maien Among Winners At Metal Hammer Awards””Metal Hammer Golden Gods Awards””Bullet For My Valentine Booed At Metal Hammer Golden Gods Awards””Metal Storm Awards 2006””Metal Storm Awards 2015””Slayer's Concert History””Slayer - Relationships””Slayer - Releases”Slayers officiella webbplatsSlayer på MusicBrainzOfficiell webbplatsSlayerSlayerr1373445760000 0001 1540 47353068615-5086262726cb13906545x(data)6033143kn20030215029