What favor did Moody owe Dumbledore?Would real Moody have taught 4th year students about Unforgiveable curses?Was there any point in Goblet of Fire film where Dumbledore becomes suspicious of Moody?What did Dumbledore ask Moody at the opening feast?How did Moody make the spider fly?Who was the victim of the curse on the DADA position in The Goblet of Fire?Why didn't Dumbledore appoint the real Mad Eye Moody to teach Defense Against Dark Arts?Why did only Hagrid and Dumbledore clap for Moody?Why did “Moody” suggest to Harry that he should consider becoming an Auror?Why did Dumbledore allow Alastor Moody to join the reconstituted Order of the Phoenix (in book 5)?Why did Alastor Moody grow rusty in his duelling skills at his old age, while Dumbledore can still fight Voldemort in his old age?
How to test the sharpness of a knife?
Can "few" be used as a subject? If so, what is the rule?
Knife as defense against stray dogs
"Marked down as someone wanting to sell shares." What does that mean?
Asserting that Atheism and Theism are both faith based positions
Single word to change groups
Why do I have a large white artefact on the rendered image?
Hackerrank All Women's Codesprint 2019: Name the Product
TDE Master Key Rotation
CLI: Get information Ubuntu releases
Exit shell with shortcut (not typing exit) that closes session properly
Is "inadequate referencing" a euphemism for plagiarism?
Turning a hard to access nut?
Does convergence of polynomials imply that of its coefficients?
Pre-Employment Background Check With Consent For Future Checks
What is it called when someone votes for an option that's not their first choice?
Why is this tree refusing to shed its dead leaves?
Is there any common country to visit for uk and schengen visa?
Inhabiting Mars versus going straight for a Dyson swarm
Animating wave motion in water
label a part of commutative diagram
Have any astronauts/cosmonauts died in space?
Can other pieces capture a threatening piece and prevent a checkmate?
Do people actually use the word "kaputt" in conversation?
What favor did Moody owe Dumbledore?
Would real Moody have taught 4th year students about Unforgiveable curses?Was there any point in Goblet of Fire film where Dumbledore becomes suspicious of Moody?What did Dumbledore ask Moody at the opening feast?How did Moody make the spider fly?Who was the victim of the curse on the DADA position in The Goblet of Fire?Why didn't Dumbledore appoint the real Mad Eye Moody to teach Defense Against Dark Arts?Why did only Hagrid and Dumbledore clap for Moody?Why did “Moody” suggest to Harry that he should consider becoming an Auror?Why did Dumbledore allow Alastor Moody to join the reconstituted Order of the Phoenix (in book 5)?Why did Alastor Moody grow rusty in his duelling skills at his old age, while Dumbledore can still fight Voldemort in his old age?
In the Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, "Moody" mentioned that he would only be teaching for a year and only because he owed Dumbledore a favor. What was this favor and what made it so important that it made Moody agree to give up a year of his life to teach DADA?
harry-potter albus-dumbledore
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
asked yesterday
Invent PaloozaInvent Palooza
8619
add a comment |
In the Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, "Moody" mentioned that he would only be teaching for a year and only because he owed Dumbledore a favor. What was this favor and what made it so important that it made Moody agree to give up a year of his life to teach DADA?
harry-potter albus-dumbledore
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
asked yesterday
Invent PaloozaInvent Palooza
8619
add a comment |
In the Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, "Moody" mentioned that he would only be teaching for a year and only because he owed Dumbledore a favor. What was this favor and what made it so important that it made Moody agree to give up a year of his life to teach DADA?
harry-potter albus-dumbledore
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
asked yesterday
Invent PaloozaInvent Palooza
8619
In the Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, "Moody" mentioned that he would only be teaching for a year and only because he owed Dumbledore a favor. What was this favor and what made it so important that it made Moody agree to give up a year of his life to teach DADA?
harry-potter albus-dumbledore
harry-potter albus-dumbledore
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
asked yesterday
Invent PaloozaInvent Palooza
8619
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
asked yesterday
Invent PaloozaInvent Palooza
8619
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
25.4k25145243
asked yesterday
Invent PaloozaInvent Palooza
8619
asked yesterday
Invent PaloozaInvent Palooza
8619
asked yesterday
Invent PaloozaInvent Palooza
8619
8619
add a comment |
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
I have a translation of the 4th book by A-ba-ba-ha-la-ma-ha, a highly respected publishing house in Ukraine.
— То це ти син Артура Візлі? — спитав Муді. — Твій батько пару днів тому витяг мене з великої халепи… Так, я пробуду тут тільки рік. І то лише заради Дамблдора... один рік, а потім знову на пенсію.
Ukrainian
"Special favor to Dumbledore...." was translated into "І то лише заради Дамблдорa..." which in Ukrainian unambiguously means "only for Dumbledore's sake".
Though, it really doesn't matter. Don't forget that it was said by Bartemius Crouch Junior who was disguised as Moody. I don't know the real reason* why Moody was invited to Hogwarts as a teacher** and I am afraid the author didn't mention it anywhere.
Nevertheless, "Special favor to Dumbledore...." is a clever reply. It lulls the pupils into thinking that Dumbledore and Moody are good old friends, and consequently raises fewer questions about Moody's past and why he is a teacher.
* The real reason why Dumbledore invited Moody to the school is the Triwizard Tournament.
** The position is vacant. I guess having an auror as a teacher is less suspicious than hiring an auror for security purposes.
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
answered yesterday
Andrew TobilkoAndrew Tobilko
2925
New contributor
Andrew Tobilko is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
1
Would this "only for Dumbledore's sake" also cover if Dumbledore says "Moody, help me, please, you are my only hope", or does it imply some obligation like repayment for something that Dumbledore did for Moody?
– RalfFriedl
15 hours ago
@RalfFriedl for sb’s sake means in order to help sb, it doesn’t imply “obligation” or “sb’s only hope”
– Andrew Tobilko
13 hours ago
15
I wouldn't take a translation as being a better source than the original in determining intent - you're highly reliant on the interpreter and their personal interpretation of the line.
– Baldrickk
9 hours ago
@Baldrickk I am not saying it’s better than the original. It was supposed to back up the post by Alex where the original quote had already been mentioned.
– Andrew Tobilko
9 hours ago
1
Come to think of it, a paranoid auditor is the most likely candidate for turning back a curse on a position.
– Joshua
5 hours ago
|
show 1 more comment
I don't think there is necessarily an indication that Moody owed Dumbledore a favor. Here is the relevant quote from Chapter Fourteen:
"You'll be Arthur Weasley's son, eh?" Moody said. "Your father got me out of a very tight corner a few days ago.... Yeah, I'm staying just the one year. Special favor to Dumbledore.... One year, and then back to my quiet retirement."
All this says is that Moody agreed to teach for one year as a favor to Dumbledore. It doesn't say that he owed a favor to Dumbledore. People do favors for others all the time, especially when they like and respect the person. Moody might simply have agreed to it because Dumbledore asked him.
answered yesterday
AlexAlex
18.5k45592
16
@InventPalooza It’s not a random act of kindness. I don’t think he would do it for many other people. But Dumbledore is his friend, they have worked together against Voldemort and the Death Eaters for many years, and he presumably highly respects him.
– Alex
yesterday
4
To show that Barty Crouch Jr knew the actual reason, you could add this quote from the end of the book from Crouch: "I kept him alive, under the Imperius Curse. I wanted to be able to question him. To find out about his past, learn his habits, so that I could fool even Dumbledore."
– Julien Lopez
yesterday
24
@InventPalooza People don't always do a favour in return for a previous favour. Sometimes they do a favour in order to call back a return favour at a later date.
– Nicola Talbot
yesterday
26
@InventPalooza - ""Special favor" implies that Moody owed Dumbledore something." No, it doesn't. Not in colloquial English (American or British). All it means is he's doing a favor for Dumbledore. The "special" modifier just means it's not a favor he'd do for just anyone, but it doesn't mean he owes Dumbledore. Just that he respects him, likes him, or whatever, and is willing to do him a favor he may not be willing to do for someone else.
– T.J. Crowder
yesterday
6
@TJCrowder: And, really, only the British dialect matters. It's what Rowling would use, and it's what her British characters in Britain would be using.
– JRE
9 hours ago
|
show 11 more comments
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "186"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f207368%2fwhat-favor-did-moody-owe-dumbledore%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
I have a translation of the 4th book by A-ba-ba-ha-la-ma-ha, a highly respected publishing house in Ukraine.
— То це ти син Артура Візлі? — спитав Муді. — Твій батько пару днів тому витяг мене з великої халепи… Так, я пробуду тут тільки рік. І то лише заради Дамблдора... один рік, а потім знову на пенсію.
Ukrainian
"Special favor to Dumbledore...." was translated into "І то лише заради Дамблдорa..." which in Ukrainian unambiguously means "only for Dumbledore's sake".
Though, it really doesn't matter. Don't forget that it was said by Bartemius Crouch Junior who was disguised as Moody. I don't know the real reason* why Moody was invited to Hogwarts as a teacher** and I am afraid the author didn't mention it anywhere.
Nevertheless, "Special favor to Dumbledore...." is a clever reply. It lulls the pupils into thinking that Dumbledore and Moody are good old friends, and consequently raises fewer questions about Moody's past and why he is a teacher.
* The real reason why Dumbledore invited Moody to the school is the Triwizard Tournament.
** The position is vacant. I guess having an auror as a teacher is less suspicious than hiring an auror for security purposes.
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
answered yesterday
Andrew TobilkoAndrew Tobilko
2925
New contributor
Andrew Tobilko is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
1
Would this "only for Dumbledore's sake" also cover if Dumbledore says "Moody, help me, please, you are my only hope", or does it imply some obligation like repayment for something that Dumbledore did for Moody?
– RalfFriedl
15 hours ago
@RalfFriedl for sb’s sake means in order to help sb, it doesn’t imply “obligation” or “sb’s only hope”
– Andrew Tobilko
13 hours ago
15
I wouldn't take a translation as being a better source than the original in determining intent - you're highly reliant on the interpreter and their personal interpretation of the line.
– Baldrickk
9 hours ago
@Baldrickk I am not saying it’s better than the original. It was supposed to back up the post by Alex where the original quote had already been mentioned.
– Andrew Tobilko
9 hours ago
1
Come to think of it, a paranoid auditor is the most likely candidate for turning back a curse on a position.
– Joshua
5 hours ago
|
show 1 more comment
I have a translation of the 4th book by A-ba-ba-ha-la-ma-ha, a highly respected publishing house in Ukraine.
— То це ти син Артура Візлі? — спитав Муді. — Твій батько пару днів тому витяг мене з великої халепи… Так, я пробуду тут тільки рік. І то лише заради Дамблдора... один рік, а потім знову на пенсію.
Ukrainian
"Special favor to Dumbledore...." was translated into "І то лише заради Дамблдорa..." which in Ukrainian unambiguously means "only for Dumbledore's sake".
Though, it really doesn't matter. Don't forget that it was said by Bartemius Crouch Junior who was disguised as Moody. I don't know the real reason* why Moody was invited to Hogwarts as a teacher** and I am afraid the author didn't mention it anywhere.
Nevertheless, "Special favor to Dumbledore...." is a clever reply. It lulls the pupils into thinking that Dumbledore and Moody are good old friends, and consequently raises fewer questions about Moody's past and why he is a teacher.
* The real reason why Dumbledore invited Moody to the school is the Triwizard Tournament.
** The position is vacant. I guess having an auror as a teacher is less suspicious than hiring an auror for security purposes.
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
answered yesterday
Andrew TobilkoAndrew Tobilko
2925
New contributor
Andrew Tobilko is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
1
Would this "only for Dumbledore's sake" also cover if Dumbledore says "Moody, help me, please, you are my only hope", or does it imply some obligation like repayment for something that Dumbledore did for Moody?
– RalfFriedl
15 hours ago
@RalfFriedl for sb’s sake means in order to help sb, it doesn’t imply “obligation” or “sb’s only hope”
– Andrew Tobilko
13 hours ago
15
I wouldn't take a translation as being a better source than the original in determining intent - you're highly reliant on the interpreter and their personal interpretation of the line.
– Baldrickk
9 hours ago
@Baldrickk I am not saying it’s better than the original. It was supposed to back up the post by Alex where the original quote had already been mentioned.
– Andrew Tobilko
9 hours ago
1
Come to think of it, a paranoid auditor is the most likely candidate for turning back a curse on a position.
– Joshua
5 hours ago
|
show 1 more comment
I have a translation of the 4th book by A-ba-ba-ha-la-ma-ha, a highly respected publishing house in Ukraine.
— То це ти син Артура Візлі? — спитав Муді. — Твій батько пару днів тому витяг мене з великої халепи… Так, я пробуду тут тільки рік. І то лише заради Дамблдора... один рік, а потім знову на пенсію.
Ukrainian
"Special favor to Dumbledore...." was translated into "І то лише заради Дамблдорa..." which in Ukrainian unambiguously means "only for Dumbledore's sake".
Though, it really doesn't matter. Don't forget that it was said by Bartemius Crouch Junior who was disguised as Moody. I don't know the real reason* why Moody was invited to Hogwarts as a teacher** and I am afraid the author didn't mention it anywhere.
Nevertheless, "Special favor to Dumbledore...." is a clever reply. It lulls the pupils into thinking that Dumbledore and Moody are good old friends, and consequently raises fewer questions about Moody's past and why he is a teacher.
* The real reason why Dumbledore invited Moody to the school is the Triwizard Tournament.
** The position is vacant. I guess having an auror as a teacher is less suspicious than hiring an auror for security purposes.
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
answered yesterday
Andrew TobilkoAndrew Tobilko
2925
New contributor
Andrew Tobilko is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
I have a translation of the 4th book by A-ba-ba-ha-la-ma-ha, a highly respected publishing house in Ukraine.
— То це ти син Артура Візлі? — спитав Муді. — Твій батько пару днів тому витяг мене з великої халепи… Так, я пробуду тут тільки рік. І то лише заради Дамблдора... один рік, а потім знову на пенсію.
Ukrainian
"Special favor to Dumbledore...." was translated into "І то лише заради Дамблдорa..." which in Ukrainian unambiguously means "only for Dumbledore's sake".
Though, it really doesn't matter. Don't forget that it was said by Bartemius Crouch Junior who was disguised as Moody. I don't know the real reason* why Moody was invited to Hogwarts as a teacher** and I am afraid the author didn't mention it anywhere.
Nevertheless, "Special favor to Dumbledore...." is a clever reply. It lulls the pupils into thinking that Dumbledore and Moody are good old friends, and consequently raises fewer questions about Moody's past and why he is a teacher.
* The real reason why Dumbledore invited Moody to the school is the Triwizard Tournament.
** The position is vacant. I guess having an auror as a teacher is less suspicious than hiring an auror for security purposes.
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
answered yesterday
Andrew TobilkoAndrew Tobilko
2925
New contributor
Andrew Tobilko is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
edited 11 hours ago
SQB
25.4k25145243
25.4k25145243
answered yesterday
Andrew TobilkoAndrew Tobilko
2925
New contributor
Andrew Tobilko is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
answered yesterday
Andrew TobilkoAndrew Tobilko
2925
answered yesterday
Andrew TobilkoAndrew Tobilko
2925
2925
New contributor
Andrew Tobilko is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
New contributor
Andrew Tobilko is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
Andrew Tobilko is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
1
Would this "only for Dumbledore's sake" also cover if Dumbledore says "Moody, help me, please, you are my only hope", or does it imply some obligation like repayment for something that Dumbledore did for Moody?
– RalfFriedl
15 hours ago
@RalfFriedl for sb’s sake means in order to help sb, it doesn’t imply “obligation” or “sb’s only hope”
– Andrew Tobilko
13 hours ago
15
I wouldn't take a translation as being a better source than the original in determining intent - you're highly reliant on the interpreter and their personal interpretation of the line.
– Baldrickk
9 hours ago
@Baldrickk I am not saying it’s better than the original. It was supposed to back up the post by Alex where the original quote had already been mentioned.
– Andrew Tobilko
9 hours ago
1
Come to think of it, a paranoid auditor is the most likely candidate for turning back a curse on a position.
– Joshua
5 hours ago
|
show 1 more comment
1
Would this "only for Dumbledore's sake" also cover if Dumbledore says "Moody, help me, please, you are my only hope", or does it imply some obligation like repayment for something that Dumbledore did for Moody?
– RalfFriedl
15 hours ago
@RalfFriedl for sb’s sake means in order to help sb, it doesn’t imply “obligation” or “sb’s only hope”
– Andrew Tobilko
13 hours ago
15
I wouldn't take a translation as being a better source than the original in determining intent - you're highly reliant on the interpreter and their personal interpretation of the line.
– Baldrickk
9 hours ago
@Baldrickk I am not saying it’s better than the original. It was supposed to back up the post by Alex where the original quote had already been mentioned.
– Andrew Tobilko
9 hours ago
1
Come to think of it, a paranoid auditor is the most likely candidate for turning back a curse on a position.
– Joshua
5 hours ago
1
1
Would this "only for Dumbledore's sake" also cover if Dumbledore says "Moody, help me, please, you are my only hope", or does it imply some obligation like repayment for something that Dumbledore did for Moody?
– RalfFriedl
15 hours ago
Would this "only for Dumbledore's sake" also cover if Dumbledore says "Moody, help me, please, you are my only hope", or does it imply some obligation like repayment for something that Dumbledore did for Moody?
– RalfFriedl
15 hours ago
@RalfFriedl for sb’s sake means in order to help sb, it doesn’t imply “obligation” or “sb’s only hope”
– Andrew Tobilko
13 hours ago
@RalfFriedl for sb’s sake means in order to help sb, it doesn’t imply “obligation” or “sb’s only hope”
– Andrew Tobilko
13 hours ago
15
15
I wouldn't take a translation as being a better source than the original in determining intent - you're highly reliant on the interpreter and their personal interpretation of the line.
– Baldrickk
9 hours ago
I wouldn't take a translation as being a better source than the original in determining intent - you're highly reliant on the interpreter and their personal interpretation of the line.
– Baldrickk
9 hours ago
@Baldrickk I am not saying it’s better than the original. It was supposed to back up the post by Alex where the original quote had already been mentioned.
– Andrew Tobilko
9 hours ago
@Baldrickk I am not saying it’s better than the original. It was supposed to back up the post by Alex where the original quote had already been mentioned.
– Andrew Tobilko
9 hours ago
1
1
Come to think of it, a paranoid auditor is the most likely candidate for turning back a curse on a position.
– Joshua
5 hours ago
Come to think of it, a paranoid auditor is the most likely candidate for turning back a curse on a position.
– Joshua
5 hours ago
|
show 1 more comment
I don't think there is necessarily an indication that Moody owed Dumbledore a favor. Here is the relevant quote from Chapter Fourteen:
"You'll be Arthur Weasley's son, eh?" Moody said. "Your father got me out of a very tight corner a few days ago.... Yeah, I'm staying just the one year. Special favor to Dumbledore.... One year, and then back to my quiet retirement."
All this says is that Moody agreed to teach for one year as a favor to Dumbledore. It doesn't say that he owed a favor to Dumbledore. People do favors for others all the time, especially when they like and respect the person. Moody might simply have agreed to it because Dumbledore asked him.
answered yesterday
AlexAlex
18.5k45592
16
@InventPalooza It’s not a random act of kindness. I don’t think he would do it for many other people. But Dumbledore is his friend, they have worked together against Voldemort and the Death Eaters for many years, and he presumably highly respects him.
– Alex
yesterday
4
To show that Barty Crouch Jr knew the actual reason, you could add this quote from the end of the book from Crouch: "I kept him alive, under the Imperius Curse. I wanted to be able to question him. To find out about his past, learn his habits, so that I could fool even Dumbledore."
– Julien Lopez
yesterday
24
@InventPalooza People don't always do a favour in return for a previous favour. Sometimes they do a favour in order to call back a return favour at a later date.
– Nicola Talbot
yesterday
26
@InventPalooza - ""Special favor" implies that Moody owed Dumbledore something." No, it doesn't. Not in colloquial English (American or British). All it means is he's doing a favor for Dumbledore. The "special" modifier just means it's not a favor he'd do for just anyone, but it doesn't mean he owes Dumbledore. Just that he respects him, likes him, or whatever, and is willing to do him a favor he may not be willing to do for someone else.
– T.J. Crowder
yesterday
6
@TJCrowder: And, really, only the British dialect matters. It's what Rowling would use, and it's what her British characters in Britain would be using.
– JRE
9 hours ago
|
show 11 more comments
I don't think there is necessarily an indication that Moody owed Dumbledore a favor. Here is the relevant quote from Chapter Fourteen:
"You'll be Arthur Weasley's son, eh?" Moody said. "Your father got me out of a very tight corner a few days ago.... Yeah, I'm staying just the one year. Special favor to Dumbledore.... One year, and then back to my quiet retirement."
All this says is that Moody agreed to teach for one year as a favor to Dumbledore. It doesn't say that he owed a favor to Dumbledore. People do favors for others all the time, especially when they like and respect the person. Moody might simply have agreed to it because Dumbledore asked him.
answered yesterday
AlexAlex
18.5k45592
16
@InventPalooza It’s not a random act of kindness. I don’t think he would do it for many other people. But Dumbledore is his friend, they have worked together against Voldemort and the Death Eaters for many years, and he presumably highly respects him.
– Alex
yesterday
4
To show that Barty Crouch Jr knew the actual reason, you could add this quote from the end of the book from Crouch: "I kept him alive, under the Imperius Curse. I wanted to be able to question him. To find out about his past, learn his habits, so that I could fool even Dumbledore."
– Julien Lopez
yesterday
24
@InventPalooza People don't always do a favour in return for a previous favour. Sometimes they do a favour in order to call back a return favour at a later date.
– Nicola Talbot
yesterday
26
@InventPalooza - ""Special favor" implies that Moody owed Dumbledore something." No, it doesn't. Not in colloquial English (American or British). All it means is he's doing a favor for Dumbledore. The "special" modifier just means it's not a favor he'd do for just anyone, but it doesn't mean he owes Dumbledore. Just that he respects him, likes him, or whatever, and is willing to do him a favor he may not be willing to do for someone else.
– T.J. Crowder
yesterday
6
@TJCrowder: And, really, only the British dialect matters. It's what Rowling would use, and it's what her British characters in Britain would be using.
– JRE
9 hours ago
|
show 11 more comments
I don't think there is necessarily an indication that Moody owed Dumbledore a favor. Here is the relevant quote from Chapter Fourteen:
"You'll be Arthur Weasley's son, eh?" Moody said. "Your father got me out of a very tight corner a few days ago.... Yeah, I'm staying just the one year. Special favor to Dumbledore.... One year, and then back to my quiet retirement."
All this says is that Moody agreed to teach for one year as a favor to Dumbledore. It doesn't say that he owed a favor to Dumbledore. People do favors for others all the time, especially when they like and respect the person. Moody might simply have agreed to it because Dumbledore asked him.
answered yesterday
AlexAlex
18.5k45592
I don't think there is necessarily an indication that Moody owed Dumbledore a favor. Here is the relevant quote from Chapter Fourteen:
"You'll be Arthur Weasley's son, eh?" Moody said. "Your father got me out of a very tight corner a few days ago.... Yeah, I'm staying just the one year. Special favor to Dumbledore.... One year, and then back to my quiet retirement."
All this says is that Moody agreed to teach for one year as a favor to Dumbledore. It doesn't say that he owed a favor to Dumbledore. People do favors for others all the time, especially when they like and respect the person. Moody might simply have agreed to it because Dumbledore asked him.
answered yesterday
AlexAlex
18.5k45592
answered yesterday
AlexAlex
18.5k45592
answered yesterday
AlexAlex
18.5k45592
answered yesterday
AlexAlex
18.5k45592
18.5k45592
16
@InventPalooza It’s not a random act of kindness. I don’t think he would do it for many other people. But Dumbledore is his friend, they have worked together against Voldemort and the Death Eaters for many years, and he presumably highly respects him.
– Alex
yesterday
4
To show that Barty Crouch Jr knew the actual reason, you could add this quote from the end of the book from Crouch: "I kept him alive, under the Imperius Curse. I wanted to be able to question him. To find out about his past, learn his habits, so that I could fool even Dumbledore."
– Julien Lopez
yesterday
24
@InventPalooza People don't always do a favour in return for a previous favour. Sometimes they do a favour in order to call back a return favour at a later date.
– Nicola Talbot
yesterday
26
@InventPalooza - ""Special favor" implies that Moody owed Dumbledore something." No, it doesn't. Not in colloquial English (American or British). All it means is he's doing a favor for Dumbledore. The "special" modifier just means it's not a favor he'd do for just anyone, but it doesn't mean he owes Dumbledore. Just that he respects him, likes him, or whatever, and is willing to do him a favor he may not be willing to do for someone else.
– T.J. Crowder
yesterday
6
@TJCrowder: And, really, only the British dialect matters. It's what Rowling would use, and it's what her British characters in Britain would be using.
– JRE
9 hours ago
|
show 11 more comments
16
@InventPalooza It’s not a random act of kindness. I don’t think he would do it for many other people. But Dumbledore is his friend, they have worked together against Voldemort and the Death Eaters for many years, and he presumably highly respects him.
– Alex
yesterday
4
To show that Barty Crouch Jr knew the actual reason, you could add this quote from the end of the book from Crouch: "I kept him alive, under the Imperius Curse. I wanted to be able to question him. To find out about his past, learn his habits, so that I could fool even Dumbledore."
– Julien Lopez
yesterday
24
@InventPalooza People don't always do a favour in return for a previous favour. Sometimes they do a favour in order to call back a return favour at a later date.
– Nicola Talbot
yesterday
26
@InventPalooza - ""Special favor" implies that Moody owed Dumbledore something." No, it doesn't. Not in colloquial English (American or British). All it means is he's doing a favor for Dumbledore. The "special" modifier just means it's not a favor he'd do for just anyone, but it doesn't mean he owes Dumbledore. Just that he respects him, likes him, or whatever, and is willing to do him a favor he may not be willing to do for someone else.
– T.J. Crowder
yesterday
6
@TJCrowder: And, really, only the British dialect matters. It's what Rowling would use, and it's what her British characters in Britain would be using.
– JRE
9 hours ago
16
16
@InventPalooza It’s not a random act of kindness. I don’t think he would do it for many other people. But Dumbledore is his friend, they have worked together against Voldemort and the Death Eaters for many years, and he presumably highly respects him.
– Alex
yesterday
@InventPalooza It’s not a random act of kindness. I don’t think he would do it for many other people. But Dumbledore is his friend, they have worked together against Voldemort and the Death Eaters for many years, and he presumably highly respects him.
– Alex
yesterday
4
4
To show that Barty Crouch Jr knew the actual reason, you could add this quote from the end of the book from Crouch: "I kept him alive, under the Imperius Curse. I wanted to be able to question him. To find out about his past, learn his habits, so that I could fool even Dumbledore."
– Julien Lopez
yesterday
To show that Barty Crouch Jr knew the actual reason, you could add this quote from the end of the book from Crouch: "I kept him alive, under the Imperius Curse. I wanted to be able to question him. To find out about his past, learn his habits, so that I could fool even Dumbledore."
– Julien Lopez
yesterday
24
24
@InventPalooza People don't always do a favour in return for a previous favour. Sometimes they do a favour in order to call back a return favour at a later date.
– Nicola Talbot
yesterday
@InventPalooza People don't always do a favour in return for a previous favour. Sometimes they do a favour in order to call back a return favour at a later date.
– Nicola Talbot
yesterday
26
26
@InventPalooza - ""Special favor" implies that Moody owed Dumbledore something." No, it doesn't. Not in colloquial English (American or British). All it means is he's doing a favor for Dumbledore. The "special" modifier just means it's not a favor he'd do for just anyone, but it doesn't mean he owes Dumbledore. Just that he respects him, likes him, or whatever, and is willing to do him a favor he may not be willing to do for someone else.
– T.J. Crowder
yesterday
@InventPalooza - ""Special favor" implies that Moody owed Dumbledore something." No, it doesn't. Not in colloquial English (American or British). All it means is he's doing a favor for Dumbledore. The "special" modifier just means it's not a favor he'd do for just anyone, but it doesn't mean he owes Dumbledore. Just that he respects him, likes him, or whatever, and is willing to do him a favor he may not be willing to do for someone else.
– T.J. Crowder
yesterday
6
6
@TJCrowder: And, really, only the British dialect matters. It's what Rowling would use, and it's what her British characters in Britain would be using.
– JRE
9 hours ago
@TJCrowder: And, really, only the British dialect matters. It's what Rowling would use, and it's what her British characters in Britain would be using.
– JRE
9 hours ago
|
show 11 more comments
Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f207368%2fwhat-favor-did-moody-owe-dumbledore%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
