Preposition stranding: is it possible to remove preposition altogether?
Here is one phrase:
This mayhem is not something to put up with.
Here "put up with" is a complete expression, so I cannot simply drop "with" or "up" from the end.
How about this one, a title for a UI element:
The list to add items to.
Can I drop "to" from the end? Will it still be valid grammar? Will the meaning still be the same?
Similarly:
The dropdown box to select items from.
Can I drop "from" from the above sentence?
Something from a kitchen:
A tray to put fruits on.
Can I just say "A tray to put fruits"? (Yes, I know, a "fruit tray" or a "tray for fruits" would be better, but this is not my question).
Is there a name for this grammar form, where a dangling preposition is dropped?
grammar prepositions
asked 13 hours ago
Rusty CoreRusty Core
1676
add a comment |
Here is one phrase:
This mayhem is not something to put up with.
Here "put up with" is a complete expression, so I cannot simply drop "with" or "up" from the end.
How about this one, a title for a UI element:
The list to add items to.
Can I drop "to" from the end? Will it still be valid grammar? Will the meaning still be the same?
Similarly:
The dropdown box to select items from.
Can I drop "from" from the above sentence?
Something from a kitchen:
A tray to put fruits on.
Can I just say "A tray to put fruits"? (Yes, I know, a "fruit tray" or a "tray for fruits" would be better, but this is not my question).
Is there a name for this grammar form, where a dangling preposition is dropped?
grammar prepositions
asked 13 hours ago
Rusty CoreRusty Core
1676
The general answer is "no" - though you could say "The dropdown box, from which to select items", "A tray on which to put fruits". It probably doesn't help much as it lengthens, rather than shortens the expressions - but I prefer them. Prepositions at the end of sentences are like sore thumbs - and if it is that to which you object, you know what to do.
– WS2
12 hours ago
Nice question. If the answers here are disappointing, try the linguistics StackE.
– Hugh
12 hours ago
add a comment |
Here is one phrase:
This mayhem is not something to put up with.
Here "put up with" is a complete expression, so I cannot simply drop "with" or "up" from the end.
How about this one, a title for a UI element:
The list to add items to.
Can I drop "to" from the end? Will it still be valid grammar? Will the meaning still be the same?
Similarly:
The dropdown box to select items from.
Can I drop "from" from the above sentence?
Something from a kitchen:
A tray to put fruits on.
Can I just say "A tray to put fruits"? (Yes, I know, a "fruit tray" or a "tray for fruits" would be better, but this is not my question).
Is there a name for this grammar form, where a dangling preposition is dropped?
grammar prepositions
asked 13 hours ago
Rusty CoreRusty Core
1676
Here is one phrase:
This mayhem is not something to put up with.
Here "put up with" is a complete expression, so I cannot simply drop "with" or "up" from the end.
How about this one, a title for a UI element:
The list to add items to.
Can I drop "to" from the end? Will it still be valid grammar? Will the meaning still be the same?
Similarly:
The dropdown box to select items from.
Can I drop "from" from the above sentence?
Something from a kitchen:
A tray to put fruits on.
Can I just say "A tray to put fruits"? (Yes, I know, a "fruit tray" or a "tray for fruits" would be better, but this is not my question).
Is there a name for this grammar form, where a dangling preposition is dropped?
grammar prepositions
grammar prepositions
asked 13 hours ago
Rusty CoreRusty Core
1676
asked 13 hours ago
Rusty CoreRusty Core
1676
asked 13 hours ago
Rusty CoreRusty Core
1676
asked 13 hours ago
Rusty CoreRusty Core
1676
asked 13 hours ago
Rusty CoreRusty Core
1676
1676
The general answer is "no" - though you could say "The dropdown box, from which to select items", "A tray on which to put fruits". It probably doesn't help much as it lengthens, rather than shortens the expressions - but I prefer them. Prepositions at the end of sentences are like sore thumbs - and if it is that to which you object, you know what to do.
– WS2
12 hours ago
Nice question. If the answers here are disappointing, try the linguistics StackE.
– Hugh
12 hours ago
add a comment |
The general answer is "no" - though you could say "The dropdown box, from which to select items", "A tray on which to put fruits". It probably doesn't help much as it lengthens, rather than shortens the expressions - but I prefer them. Prepositions at the end of sentences are like sore thumbs - and if it is that to which you object, you know what to do.
– WS2
12 hours ago
Nice question. If the answers here are disappointing, try the linguistics StackE.
– Hugh
12 hours ago
The general answer is "no" - though you could say "The dropdown box, from which to select items", "A tray on which to put fruits". It probably doesn't help much as it lengthens, rather than shortens the expressions - but I prefer them. Prepositions at the end of sentences are like sore thumbs - and if it is that to which you object, you know what to do.
– WS2
12 hours ago
The general answer is "no" - though you could say "The dropdown box, from which to select items", "A tray on which to put fruits". It probably doesn't help much as it lengthens, rather than shortens the expressions - but I prefer them. Prepositions at the end of sentences are like sore thumbs - and if it is that to which you object, you know what to do.
– WS2
12 hours ago
Nice question. If the answers here are disappointing, try the linguistics StackE.
– Hugh
12 hours ago
Nice question. If the answers here are disappointing, try the linguistics StackE.
– Hugh
12 hours ago
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
By removing the preposition you'd be turning an intransitive verb into a transitive verb. This may work in certain cases, because there are some verbs that can either be transitive or intransitive. However, the transitive and intransitive versions of verbs often have different meanings. In that case, removing the preposition may result in a valid sentence with a different meaning.
Examples:
The list to add [transitive] items to -> the list to which items are added
The list to add [intransitive] items -> the list whose purpose is adding items
The dropdown box to select [intransitive] items from -> the list from which items can be selected
The dropdown box to select [transitive] items -> the list whose purpose is selecting items
I need someone to talk [intransitive] to -> I require a conversation partner
I need someone to talk [transitive] -> I require that someone speak
The car must not be jumped [intransitive] on -> Don't climb on the car and jump on it
The car must not be jumped [transitive] -> Don't jump start the car/Don't leap over the car
The climbing wall should not be climbed [intransitive] on -> Don't use your hands and feet to move around on the wall
The climbing wall should not be climbed [transitive] -> Don't use your hands and feet to ascend the wall (hey, this one pretty much works!)
Put does not have a transitive sense, so a tray cannot "put fruits."
answered 11 hours ago
JuhaszJuhasz
2,7131511
Don't jump and climb on the car.
– Lambie
11 hours ago
Ooh, climb is an example that does work (mostly). Thanks, @Lambie
– Juhasz
11 hours ago
1
No worries. :) Not sure that a climbing wall is climbed on usually. The children climb on the furniture, but I climb climbing walls. Right?
– Lambie
11 hours ago
I think a case that works is "Whom are you calling to?" and "Whom are you calling?" but in this case "to" is almost unnecessary.
– Rusty Core
10 hours ago
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "97"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});
function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});
}
});
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fenglish.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f491459%2fpreposition-stranding-is-it-possible-to-remove-preposition-altogether%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
By removing the preposition you'd be turning an intransitive verb into a transitive verb. This may work in certain cases, because there are some verbs that can either be transitive or intransitive. However, the transitive and intransitive versions of verbs often have different meanings. In that case, removing the preposition may result in a valid sentence with a different meaning.
Examples:
The list to add [transitive] items to -> the list to which items are added
The list to add [intransitive] items -> the list whose purpose is adding items
The dropdown box to select [intransitive] items from -> the list from which items can be selected
The dropdown box to select [transitive] items -> the list whose purpose is selecting items
I need someone to talk [intransitive] to -> I require a conversation partner
I need someone to talk [transitive] -> I require that someone speak
The car must not be jumped [intransitive] on -> Don't climb on the car and jump on it
The car must not be jumped [transitive] -> Don't jump start the car/Don't leap over the car
The climbing wall should not be climbed [intransitive] on -> Don't use your hands and feet to move around on the wall
The climbing wall should not be climbed [transitive] -> Don't use your hands and feet to ascend the wall (hey, this one pretty much works!)
Put does not have a transitive sense, so a tray cannot "put fruits."
answered 11 hours ago
JuhaszJuhasz
2,7131511
Don't jump and climb on the car.
– Lambie
11 hours ago
Ooh, climb is an example that does work (mostly). Thanks, @Lambie
– Juhasz
11 hours ago
1
No worries. :) Not sure that a climbing wall is climbed on usually. The children climb on the furniture, but I climb climbing walls. Right?
– Lambie
11 hours ago
I think a case that works is "Whom are you calling to?" and "Whom are you calling?" but in this case "to" is almost unnecessary.
– Rusty Core
10 hours ago
add a comment |
By removing the preposition you'd be turning an intransitive verb into a transitive verb. This may work in certain cases, because there are some verbs that can either be transitive or intransitive. However, the transitive and intransitive versions of verbs often have different meanings. In that case, removing the preposition may result in a valid sentence with a different meaning.
Examples:
The list to add [transitive] items to -> the list to which items are added
The list to add [intransitive] items -> the list whose purpose is adding items
The dropdown box to select [intransitive] items from -> the list from which items can be selected
The dropdown box to select [transitive] items -> the list whose purpose is selecting items
I need someone to talk [intransitive] to -> I require a conversation partner
I need someone to talk [transitive] -> I require that someone speak
The car must not be jumped [intransitive] on -> Don't climb on the car and jump on it
The car must not be jumped [transitive] -> Don't jump start the car/Don't leap over the car
The climbing wall should not be climbed [intransitive] on -> Don't use your hands and feet to move around on the wall
The climbing wall should not be climbed [transitive] -> Don't use your hands and feet to ascend the wall (hey, this one pretty much works!)
Put does not have a transitive sense, so a tray cannot "put fruits."
answered 11 hours ago
JuhaszJuhasz
2,7131511
Don't jump and climb on the car.
– Lambie
11 hours ago
Ooh, climb is an example that does work (mostly). Thanks, @Lambie
– Juhasz
11 hours ago
1
No worries. :) Not sure that a climbing wall is climbed on usually. The children climb on the furniture, but I climb climbing walls. Right?
– Lambie
11 hours ago
I think a case that works is "Whom are you calling to?" and "Whom are you calling?" but in this case "to" is almost unnecessary.
– Rusty Core
10 hours ago
add a comment |
By removing the preposition you'd be turning an intransitive verb into a transitive verb. This may work in certain cases, because there are some verbs that can either be transitive or intransitive. However, the transitive and intransitive versions of verbs often have different meanings. In that case, removing the preposition may result in a valid sentence with a different meaning.
Examples:
The list to add [transitive] items to -> the list to which items are added
The list to add [intransitive] items -> the list whose purpose is adding items
The dropdown box to select [intransitive] items from -> the list from which items can be selected
The dropdown box to select [transitive] items -> the list whose purpose is selecting items
I need someone to talk [intransitive] to -> I require a conversation partner
I need someone to talk [transitive] -> I require that someone speak
The car must not be jumped [intransitive] on -> Don't climb on the car and jump on it
The car must not be jumped [transitive] -> Don't jump start the car/Don't leap over the car
The climbing wall should not be climbed [intransitive] on -> Don't use your hands and feet to move around on the wall
The climbing wall should not be climbed [transitive] -> Don't use your hands and feet to ascend the wall (hey, this one pretty much works!)
Put does not have a transitive sense, so a tray cannot "put fruits."
answered 11 hours ago
JuhaszJuhasz
2,7131511
By removing the preposition you'd be turning an intransitive verb into a transitive verb. This may work in certain cases, because there are some verbs that can either be transitive or intransitive. However, the transitive and intransitive versions of verbs often have different meanings. In that case, removing the preposition may result in a valid sentence with a different meaning.
Examples:
The list to add [transitive] items to -> the list to which items are added
The list to add [intransitive] items -> the list whose purpose is adding items
The dropdown box to select [intransitive] items from -> the list from which items can be selected
The dropdown box to select [transitive] items -> the list whose purpose is selecting items
I need someone to talk [intransitive] to -> I require a conversation partner
I need someone to talk [transitive] -> I require that someone speak
The car must not be jumped [intransitive] on -> Don't climb on the car and jump on it
The car must not be jumped [transitive] -> Don't jump start the car/Don't leap over the car
The climbing wall should not be climbed [intransitive] on -> Don't use your hands and feet to move around on the wall
The climbing wall should not be climbed [transitive] -> Don't use your hands and feet to ascend the wall (hey, this one pretty much works!)
Put does not have a transitive sense, so a tray cannot "put fruits."
answered 11 hours ago
JuhaszJuhasz
2,7131511
edited 11 hours ago
answered 11 hours ago
JuhaszJuhasz
2,7131511
answered 11 hours ago
JuhaszJuhasz
2,7131511
answered 11 hours ago
JuhaszJuhasz
2,7131511
2,7131511
Don't jump and climb on the car.
– Lambie
11 hours ago
Ooh, climb is an example that does work (mostly). Thanks, @Lambie
– Juhasz
11 hours ago
1
No worries. :) Not sure that a climbing wall is climbed on usually. The children climb on the furniture, but I climb climbing walls. Right?
– Lambie
11 hours ago
I think a case that works is "Whom are you calling to?" and "Whom are you calling?" but in this case "to" is almost unnecessary.
– Rusty Core
10 hours ago
add a comment |
Don't jump and climb on the car.
– Lambie
11 hours ago
Ooh, climb is an example that does work (mostly). Thanks, @Lambie
– Juhasz
11 hours ago
1
No worries. :) Not sure that a climbing wall is climbed on usually. The children climb on the furniture, but I climb climbing walls. Right?
– Lambie
11 hours ago
I think a case that works is "Whom are you calling to?" and "Whom are you calling?" but in this case "to" is almost unnecessary.
– Rusty Core
10 hours ago
Don't jump and climb on the car.
– Lambie
11 hours ago
Don't jump and climb on the car.
– Lambie
11 hours ago
Ooh, climb is an example that does work (mostly). Thanks, @Lambie
– Juhasz
11 hours ago
Ooh, climb is an example that does work (mostly). Thanks, @Lambie
– Juhasz
11 hours ago
1
1
No worries. :) Not sure that a climbing wall is climbed on usually. The children climb on the furniture, but I climb climbing walls. Right?
– Lambie
11 hours ago
No worries. :) Not sure that a climbing wall is climbed on usually. The children climb on the furniture, but I climb climbing walls. Right?
– Lambie
11 hours ago
I think a case that works is "Whom are you calling to?" and "Whom are you calling?" but in this case "to" is almost unnecessary.
– Rusty Core
10 hours ago
I think a case that works is "Whom are you calling to?" and "Whom are you calling?" but in this case "to" is almost unnecessary.
– Rusty Core
10 hours ago
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to English Language & Usage Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fenglish.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f491459%2fpreposition-stranding-is-it-possible-to-remove-preposition-altogether%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
The general answer is "no" - though you could say "The dropdown box, from which to select items", "A tray on which to put fruits". It probably doesn't help much as it lengthens, rather than shortens the expressions - but I prefer them. Prepositions at the end of sentences are like sore thumbs - and if it is that to which you object, you know what to do.
– WS2
12 hours ago
Nice question. If the answers here are disappointing, try the linguistics StackE.
– Hugh
12 hours ago