Why did I need to *reboot* to change my group membership [duplicate]
Multi tool use
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty{ margin-bottom:0;
}
This question already has an answer here:
After adding a group, logout+login is not enough in 18.04?
3 answers
Attempting to install MythTV on Ubuntu 18.04, I ran...
sudo usermod -a -G mythtv roger
...and logged out and back in. This should be sufficient. But: my group memberships didn't change.
I had to reboot. Why?
18.04 user-management groups
asked May 12 at 14:31
Roger LipscombeRoger Lipscombe
202111
marked as duplicate by user535733, Fabby, Eric Carvalho, qbi, pomsky May 14 at 5:21
This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.
add a comment |
This question already has an answer here:
After adding a group, logout+login is not enough in 18.04?
3 answers
Attempting to install MythTV on Ubuntu 18.04, I ran...
sudo usermod -a -G mythtv roger
...and logged out and back in. This should be sufficient. But: my group memberships didn't change.
I had to reboot. Why?
18.04 user-management groups
asked May 12 at 14:31
Roger LipscombeRoger Lipscombe
202111
marked as duplicate by user535733, Fabby, Eric Carvalho, qbi, pomsky May 14 at 5:21
This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.
Could very well be the cause in the linked dupe. systemd strikes again, I guess.
– Roger Lipscombe
May 12 at 21:54
add a comment |
This question already has an answer here:
After adding a group, logout+login is not enough in 18.04?
3 answers
Attempting to install MythTV on Ubuntu 18.04, I ran...
sudo usermod -a -G mythtv roger
...and logged out and back in. This should be sufficient. But: my group memberships didn't change.
I had to reboot. Why?
18.04 user-management groups
asked May 12 at 14:31
Roger LipscombeRoger Lipscombe
202111
This question already has an answer here:
After adding a group, logout+login is not enough in 18.04?
3 answers
Attempting to install MythTV on Ubuntu 18.04, I ran...
sudo usermod -a -G mythtv roger
...and logged out and back in. This should be sufficient. But: my group memberships didn't change.
I had to reboot. Why?
This question already has an answer here:
After adding a group, logout+login is not enough in 18.04?
3 answers
18.04 user-management groups
18.04 user-management groups
asked May 12 at 14:31
Roger LipscombeRoger Lipscombe
202111
asked May 12 at 14:31
Roger LipscombeRoger Lipscombe
202111
asked May 12 at 14:31
Roger LipscombeRoger Lipscombe
202111
asked May 12 at 14:31
Roger LipscombeRoger Lipscombe
202111
asked May 12 at 14:31
Roger LipscombeRoger Lipscombe
202111
202111
marked as duplicate by user535733, Fabby, Eric Carvalho, qbi, pomsky May 14 at 5:21
This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.
marked as duplicate by user535733, Fabby, Eric Carvalho, qbi, pomsky May 14 at 5:21
This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.
Could very well be the cause in the linked dupe. systemd strikes again, I guess.
– Roger Lipscombe
May 12 at 21:54
add a comment |
Could very well be the cause in the linked dupe. systemd strikes again, I guess.
– Roger Lipscombe
May 12 at 21:54
Could very well be the cause in the linked dupe. systemd strikes again, I guess.
– Roger Lipscombe
May 12 at 21:54
Could very well be the cause in the linked dupe. systemd strikes again, I guess.
– Roger Lipscombe
May 12 at 21:54
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
Likely because /etc/gshadow was not updated (but don't ask me why that didn't happen as usermod should do that too; check /var/log/ if there is a notice). The 2 files important for groups are /etc/group and /etc/gshadow where gshadow supersedes group.
When both are correct logging out and in is enough to update the group for the user. If only the 1st was updated you will need to reboot or you can update gshadow with the grpconv command. Logging out and in is then enough.
answered May 12 at 14:45
RinzwindRinzwind
214k28413552
4
Why does reboot fix it then?
– Joshua
May 12 at 19:11
1
A bug in systemd where they created a fix during boot
– Rinzwind
May 13 at 6:13
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
Likely because /etc/gshadow was not updated (but don't ask me why that didn't happen as usermod should do that too; check /var/log/ if there is a notice). The 2 files important for groups are /etc/group and /etc/gshadow where gshadow supersedes group.
When both are correct logging out and in is enough to update the group for the user. If only the 1st was updated you will need to reboot or you can update gshadow with the grpconv command. Logging out and in is then enough.
answered May 12 at 14:45
RinzwindRinzwind
214k28413552
4
Why does reboot fix it then?
– Joshua
May 12 at 19:11
1
A bug in systemd where they created a fix during boot
– Rinzwind
May 13 at 6:13
add a comment |
Likely because /etc/gshadow was not updated (but don't ask me why that didn't happen as usermod should do that too; check /var/log/ if there is a notice). The 2 files important for groups are /etc/group and /etc/gshadow where gshadow supersedes group.
When both are correct logging out and in is enough to update the group for the user. If only the 1st was updated you will need to reboot or you can update gshadow with the grpconv command. Logging out and in is then enough.
answered May 12 at 14:45
RinzwindRinzwind
214k28413552
4
Why does reboot fix it then?
– Joshua
May 12 at 19:11
1
A bug in systemd where they created a fix during boot
– Rinzwind
May 13 at 6:13
add a comment |
Likely because /etc/gshadow was not updated (but don't ask me why that didn't happen as usermod should do that too; check /var/log/ if there is a notice). The 2 files important for groups are /etc/group and /etc/gshadow where gshadow supersedes group.
When both are correct logging out and in is enough to update the group for the user. If only the 1st was updated you will need to reboot or you can update gshadow with the grpconv command. Logging out and in is then enough.
answered May 12 at 14:45
RinzwindRinzwind
214k28413552
Likely because /etc/gshadow was not updated (but don't ask me why that didn't happen as usermod should do that too; check /var/log/ if there is a notice). The 2 files important for groups are /etc/group and /etc/gshadow where gshadow supersedes group.
When both are correct logging out and in is enough to update the group for the user. If only the 1st was updated you will need to reboot or you can update gshadow with the grpconv command. Logging out and in is then enough.
answered May 12 at 14:45
RinzwindRinzwind
214k28413552
answered May 12 at 14:45
RinzwindRinzwind
214k28413552
answered May 12 at 14:45
RinzwindRinzwind
214k28413552
answered May 12 at 14:45
RinzwindRinzwind
214k28413552
214k28413552
4
Why does reboot fix it then?
– Joshua
May 12 at 19:11
1
A bug in systemd where they created a fix during boot
– Rinzwind
May 13 at 6:13
add a comment |
4
Why does reboot fix it then?
– Joshua
May 12 at 19:11
1
A bug in systemd where they created a fix during boot
– Rinzwind
May 13 at 6:13
4
4
Why does reboot fix it then?
– Joshua
May 12 at 19:11
Why does reboot fix it then?
– Joshua
May 12 at 19:11
1
1
A bug in systemd where they created a fix during boot
– Rinzwind
May 13 at 6:13
A bug in systemd where they created a fix during boot
– Rinzwind
May 13 at 6:13
add a comment |
sQY,mXAmxjGxMIofqFITdximWMlI,5tCCl9p8 4bwHc,fyCNgOLJI7z
Could very well be the cause in the linked dupe. systemd strikes again, I guess.
– Roger Lipscombe
May 12 at 21:54